UFO Conjectures

Sunday, October 22, 2017

UFOs: Reality & Reason

Copyright 2017, InterAmerica, Inc.

I’m taking a title from a book I have that confronts various philosophical musings about reality. The author is Sean Sayers:
The book’s full title is Reality and Reason: Dialectic and the Theory of Knowledge [Basil Blackwell, 1985].

To get at an explanation of UFOs one has to know what reality they are dealing with, and there are kinds of reality, according to philosophers, and now neurologists, among others.

My Canadian, academic pal (teacher and poet) Bryan Sentes dismissed Dr. Sayers’ book when I told him I had bought it.

I think he did so because Professor Sayers dismisses Kant, whom Bryan idolizes I believe.

Dr. Sayers opens his almost pithy book with a presentation of “Traditional Form of Realism” [Part 1, Realism an its Critics: The Empiricist Argument] offering the views of Locke and Berkeley.

Setting up a take down of Locke, Dr. Sayers writes this, which applies (or can) to UFOs:

“In many cases … there seems to be a discrepancy between the way things appear and the way they really are, between our subjective view … and what is objectively the case. We are subject to errors and illusions: what is manifest to us is not real … what is real is often not immediately apparent or manifest, but can be discovered and known only as the result of a process of investigation and thought. In short, there seems to be a real distinction between appearance and reality, between what is subjective and what is objective.” [Page 4]

“We [according to Locke] are immediately aware of ideas not things, of subjective appearances not objective reality; we are aware of things only as phenomena and not as they are in themselves …

“ … the mind for Locke is like a camera which, when acted upon by external objects, registers impressions and ideas that reflect and resemble those objects …

“ .. the mind, again, like a camera, is thus passive in the reception of experience, merely recording ideas and images impressed upon it by the senses …” {Page 6]

But Berkeley argues “experience gives us no access to the world as it is in itself; it informs us only of how the world appears to us.” [Page 7]

“Berkeley arrives at pure subjective idealism: things are nothing in themselves, they are mere ‘collections of ideas’, ‘constructions’ of appearances …

“Our knowledge is confined to ideas – we are trapped within the realm of appearances and can never know anything beyond them.” [Page 8]

Sayers then allows that the arch criminal communist Lenin provides a dialectical and materialist approach as a response to Berkeley: “there is definitely no difference in principle between the phenomenon and the thing-in-itself, and there can be no difference.” [Page 10]

Sayers writes “Locke’s dualist realism and Berkeley’s idealism has the effect of ‘fencing off’ the way things appear to us from the way they are in themselves.” [Page 10]

For ufologists (UFO buffs) this has posed problems for an explanation of what the UFO phenomenon is (or may be).

In Part 2 Dr, Sayers offers Kant’s views, which he writes are so fashionable, “enjoying an enormous vogue and influence.”

“The senses by themselves, in Kant’s words, give us a mere ‘manifold’ of impressions – a chaotic collection, an unrelated series, of impressions.” Knowledge begins only when this manifold [of impressions] is given form and order, only when it is brought under concepts and interpreted. This is the work of thought and reason. As Descartes says, neither our imagination nor our senses can ever assure us of anything at all … “ [Page 19]

Kant’s reality is circumscribed by what he called things-in-themselves [das Ding an sich].

(For this posting, that “das Ding an sich” would be UFOs.)

Kant’s view is this: “A gulf is … created between the thing-in-itself, the ‘real object’ … and the thing as it is grasped and known by us …Our knowledge, Kant … argues, is necessarily confined to appearances, and we can never gain knowledge of things-in-themselves [UFOs for this presentation].

Hegel differs with Kant: “thought does not … as at first appears, cut us off from the thing-in-itself. Rather, it helps us to grasp and to understand reality more fully and completely.” [Page 25]

So, we UFO buffs can’t throw up our hands in despair and agree with Kant that UFOs [the things-in-themselves] cannot be known.

We have to accept the Hegelian view that thought (conjecture and contemplation) are tools which will possibly bring us to a full knowledge as to what UFOs are, what the phenomenon is, not just what it represents.

I know this is a crusty way to get to my point above, but it is necessary to approach the matter (the core item for study in “ufology”) with the idea that it is amenable to understanding, if thought is applied rigorously, which is something that few, if any, UFO people I know do or have done.

RR

5 Comments:

  • Paul sent this as an e-mail, apparently not able to add it as a comment here:

    prporter
    12:35 AM (6 hours ago)

    "Never lose sight of the fact that is our mind that imposes order on the world and allows senses to be converted to things we can talk about. None of us perceive experiences directly but only through the intermediation of the brain. If your brain only has 3 concepts then nothing beyond those three can appear in you narrative…

    So, what is reality…"

    paul

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, October 23, 2017  

  • RR,

    Beginning, with an inescapable pun, delightful thoughtful post that takes me back to the CSC's freshman class The Philosophy of Knowledge that at that time, and my age of 19, was a tedious to almost boring class that grew ever more intelligently important over the years following. As I recall it started with Descartes (a favorite) and carried through the term with a survey of epistemological perspectives, all with a Thomistic undercurrent, and an avoidance of existentialism.

    Perception without physical access or contact indeed sets one up for errors borne of our limited senses as we have noted here before. Humorously, a late last night TV watching of Blazing Saddles has the Sheriff and townsmen construct a movie set like facade of their town to save the town in order to save it from the bad guys -fooled with the town's image without its (actual)substance.

    In UFO/UAP consideration Unidentified (the question) Flying (lack of physical access) Objects (the observed but undefined) present us with our topic here, reasonable conjecture awaiting further defining access (Hegel more than Kant). A seeing these untouchable and unfathomable things, [most importantly for those of us who have], is a set up for unwarranted projections while that kernel of observation remains and teases us.

    BD

    By Blogger Bryan Daum, at Monday, October 23, 2017  

  • ``...possibly bring us to a full knowledge as to what UFOs are...``

    No. Fuller, perhaps. But not full/complete. As finite creatures, our knowledge will never be that of omniscience.

    By Blogger Parakletos, at Tuesday, October 24, 2017  

  • > it is amenable to understanding, if thought is applied rigorously

    I'm with you, Rich, but as you suggest, most UFO buffs seem incapable or indifferent to intellectual rigour.

    Today I was reading the memoir of an alien abduction investigator formerly of the LA branch of MUFON. He gave a definition of PTSD without quoting or citing any references. Perhaps that was intentional, as his notions of the etiology of traumatic effects was wholly subservient to the needs of abduction proponents:

    "PTSD is defined as a mental health condition that's triggered by a terrifying event. It can happen either by experiencing it or witnessing it." (Pete Elmore, Reflections of an Alien Abduction Investigator, CreateSpace, 2015, p 12.)

    I have emphasised the word "event." The writer's definition makes it clear that if you report trauma, then, of necessity, the purported "event" occurred. It's a very tendentious definition, one the medical literature does not support.

    I have also been reading a history of trauma and war. Physicians in WWI were puzzled by "the surprisingly common occurrence of neurotic disorders behind the lines and in men who had never seen combat. These figures ultimately outweighed the numbers of neurotic soldiers who had actually been at the front."
    After giving quotes from and citations of several wartime studies, the writer summarises:
    "The cumulative effect of these observations was that the connection between traumatic experiences and neurotic symptoms was becoming ever more distant...While the research on prisoners and the severely wounded showed that large samples of soldiers who had been exposed to battle conditions did not develop neurotic conditions, studies on civilians safely distanced from the field seemed to confirm that neuroses could occur in the complete absence of traumatic battle experience" (Traumatic Pasts: History, Psychiatry and Trauma in the Modern Age, 1870-1930, Micale and Lerners, eds., Cambridge, 2001, pp 160-162).

    A century ago, many doctors thought like the abduction proponents: traumatic symptoms resulted from traumatic events. But French and German physicians tested this theory by doing surveys of private practices, hospital wards, and prisoner of war camps.

    Rigourous thought, applied.

    By Blogger Terry the Censor, at Wednesday, October 25, 2017  

  • Ah, Terry..

    You bring erudition to this blog. Thanks.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 25, 2017  

Post a Comment

<< Home