The SETI Silence: An immutable meme
Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.
That SETI isn’t receiving any signals from an
extraterrestrial civilization doesn’t surprise.
If anyone or anything exists off Earth, they or it have been
non-communicative for a long time, maybe forever.
We’re all familiar with the plight of the Hebrews, from
their earliest days up through the Holocaust, pleading with their God for
sustenance and aid in dire times.
The Jews never heard from their God.
Christians have asked for divine aid almost as often as the
Jews but they, too, have been treated viciously: Giordano Bruno, Jeanne d’Arc,
even Jesus Himself
At the beginning of Israelite times, myth (The Hebrew
Bible, Torah, et cetera) has God responding, often face-to-face with
His “chosen people.” But it’s myth, is it not?
In any case, such interaction(s) ended almost immediately at
the (venerated, alleged) death of Jesus/Christ.
The theological reason for this ending of God’s
communication may be found in Carl Jung’s exquisite rationale for God’s
withdrawal from human activity: Answer To Job.
For a most brilliant exegesis of the disappearing voice of
God, see Richard Elliott Friedman’s The Hidden Face of God (originally
published as The Disappearance of God, [HarperSanFrancisco, 1995], often
cited here, at this blog, and elsewhere.
Religious humans have begged, often, for salvation from God
but it never actually comes, although con-incidental surcease is seen as such
by the forlorn.
The Early Greeks provided mythic material telling of contact
with their Gods but no rational thinker of those early eras (philosophers,
poets, and historians) pretended that the Gods actually communicated with their
fellow Greeks.
Julian Jaynes proposed that Neolithic man, primitive man
internalized the idea of God, because no God presented itself?
(See previous material here about Jaynes’ superb, unique
insights.)
The primitive peoples of Northern Europe, Asia, Africa, the
Americas, the northern climes, and other geographical areas, worship God or
gods but accommodating Gods, actually communicating with peoples of those
geographies are absent in their extant literature.
Persons enamored of communicating with the dead have been
stiffed by silence and no proven response.
UFO fanatics, trying for contact, at gatherings or using
“technical devices,” with the supposed occupants of flying saucers, have come
away empty handed and empty headed.
SETI, scouring the skies with advanced radio telescopes,
have received nothing but the sounds of silence; the galaxy and Universe mute
as a French mime.
Human beings, we, are alone, in this existence. Not to know
that bespeaks a delusional madness.
And persons awaiting voices from afar – very afar – should
be constrained by people qualified to keep them from hurting themselves or
others.
RR


11 Comments:
It's my understanding that even with the latest receivers, antennas & processing equipment, SETI can't detect electromagnetic leakage from any extraterrestrial civilization, near or far, only narrow (1 Hz or so) directed transmissions. The probability that an extraterrestrial civilization is beaming a beacon towards us, at any time, is likely as close to zero as you can get.
By
jlmet, at Friday, April 06, 2018
THE EeRiE SILEnCe:
Best hope your wrong, and hope for Disclosure, on "both accounts."
If this were true, why are we here on Earth at all, & HOW?..FROM WHAT???..
THE BIG BANG!? Yeah Right!!!
Why does, one side of the moon, face us at all times, in its obit around Earth, THAT, is no coincidence, so who or what, made it that way? if there is no God or even, other life out there in the Universe!??? Don't give us the Evolutional theory of natural selection, that didn't put the moon in the location its in, for high tide or low. There was, and still is, a powerful intelligence at work here, and the moons location to Earth, shows that for one!................
By
Daniel, at Friday, April 06, 2018
I hope Daniel your comment isn't referencing my posting, because if it is, you have misread it mightily.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Friday, April 06, 2018
Rich, I'm addressing anyone who believes that, to think again, on that which I've pointed out...Don't try to belittle your readers, they know what they read, it's your post!!...............
By
Daniel, at Saturday, April 07, 2018
Thank you Daniel...
I just wanted to make sure you didn't misunderstand me.
(Most people do.)
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Saturday, April 07, 2018
Emptying your tackle box daniel?
By
Unknown, at Saturday, April 07, 2018
dubious f:)
Off topic, my dubious friend:)............
By
Daniel, at Saturday, April 07, 2018
> Why does one side of the moon face us at all times...THAT, is no coincidence, so who or what, made it that way?
Physics.
Lack of understanding is not sufficient warrant to postulate invisible superpowerful agents.
By
Terry the Censor, at Monday, April 09, 2018
In that case, Terry, you are "postulating" that there is no invisible superpowerful agents....Each to his own, yeah?...............
By
Daniel, at Tuesday, April 10, 2018
> Terry, you are "postulating" that there is no invisible superpowerful agents
Wrong on two counts.
Read my comment. I cited physics.
And my critique of your postulation is only that, an engagement of your illogic; it is not implicitly a statement by me on the existence or non-existence of anything.
By
Terry the Censor, at Wednesday, April 11, 2018
You CITED physics, YES! and you say; it is not implicitly a statement by you on the existence or non-existence of anything. Sooo, what's your point? What is so illogic with my comment above, that bothers you, since YOU, brought it up!?...
It's only my point of view. Right or wrong, it could be someone else's, and it is, in my circle of friends..............
By
Daniel, at Wednesday, April 11, 2018
Post a Comment
<< Home