Books and reading on the rise again but distractions still intrude
The September 2, 2019 New Yorker has a piece by Dan Chiasson on how book reading is (and has always been?) "corrupted" by distractions: Reader, I Googled It [Page 60 ff.]
It's also about how books are on the rise again.
This is a good read for my Canadian pal and scholar - poet Bryan Sentes and my buddy, profound skeptic Zoam Chomsky.
Dr Dee, Matty, Jerry Cornelius, Dvelys (I bet) and book collector but late-to-comment Terry the Censor should find the article interesting also, as should Don and Tim Hebert.
Daniel and Phil should give it a go.
My pals and authors Kevin Randle, Nick Redfern, Jose Caravaca and media creator Paul Kimball will like Mr. Chiasson's take on the current book/reading milieu because they live it.
Mr. Chiasson writes, "When a book sits next to the Internet, its authority as the final word on anything is automatically undermined," which he explains adroitly.
My point in noting the piece (and those who should read it, for various reasons) goes to the heart of my impression that there is some slippage in dexterous reading by almost everyone I know, except for Bryan Sentes.
Bryan showed me a pile of books on the floor of his about-to-be abandoned apartment for new digs to accommodate his continually increasing personal library. And in his link to show me the pile is a list of titles that I envy to the point of breaking one of the Ten Commandments:
http://bryansentes.com/2018/05/04/whats-on-my-desk-what-im-working-on/
RR
It's also about how books are on the rise again.
This is a good read for my Canadian pal and scholar - poet Bryan Sentes and my buddy, profound skeptic Zoam Chomsky.
Dr Dee, Matty, Jerry Cornelius, Dvelys (I bet) and book collector but late-to-comment Terry the Censor should find the article interesting also, as should Don and Tim Hebert.
Daniel and Phil should give it a go.
My pals and authors Kevin Randle, Nick Redfern, Jose Caravaca and media creator Paul Kimball will like Mr. Chiasson's take on the current book/reading milieu because they live it.
Mr. Chiasson writes, "When a book sits next to the Internet, its authority as the final word on anything is automatically undermined," which he explains adroitly.
My point in noting the piece (and those who should read it, for various reasons) goes to the heart of my impression that there is some slippage in dexterous reading by almost everyone I know, except for Bryan Sentes.
Bryan showed me a pile of books on the floor of his about-to-be abandoned apartment for new digs to accommodate his continually increasing personal library. And in his link to show me the pile is a list of titles that I envy to the point of breaking one of the Ten Commandments:
http://bryansentes.com/2018/05/04/whats-on-my-desk-what-im-working-on/


16 Comments:
Are we using books as an unhealthy escape from reality?
The second dilemma...
// Mr. Chiasson writes, "When a book sits next to the Internet, its authority as the final word on anything is automatically undermined," //
The brainpower/energy required to filter out misinformation/manipulation is enormous. Maybe Elon Musk is on to something when he states humans must become cyborgs.. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/elon-musk-humans-must-become-cyborgs
To be able to download knowledge (books) and process into memory could be a result of the above technology. The mountain of books we never get round to finishing (or starting) would be a thing of the past.
By
Dvelys, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
-> I envy to the point of breaking one of the Ten Commandments:<-
Worth a smile:) Rich? But where does Bryan get the time to read all that stuff? He's like a book worm!:) I don't envy him, having to shift all that, to resettle!? We might not hear from him for a while!? However, It's interesting, to read you two, head on,in disagreeing,Conjecture, despite all the books you two both read!? A friendly squabble we might think:) Don't let him go to the weeds, he's gold! you too!.........
By
Daniel, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
Dvelys:
Books are real. Your rhetorical question hinges on a certain philosophy of language and the linguistic arts, namely, that they are both essentially "representational". You seem to think the sign can be cast aside once its referent has been grasped in reality, which betrays a deep misconstrual of the whole matter (in which you are hardly alone).
Moreover, though we can surely distinguish between true and false information (information vs mis-, if I understand you correctly), there is no language use free of rhetoric, though rhetoric need not be manipulative, though I remain unsure of just what you might have in mind, there. E.g., Musk's proposal is as misinformed as it is manipulative!
But books are not mere repositories of knowledge that is "processed" into memory. Obviously I speak from a humanistically inflected education (German 'Bildung' or French 'formation' would be better words in this instance). Even Francis Bacon, who eschewed ornamentation, had a style (and he wrote _The New Atlantis_), as did even Freud (famously), Einstein, and Schroedinger. That is, none of their works were mere media for the noiseless communication of information (such transparency being itself, famously, a rhetorical effect).
Musk's Saskatchewan-born mother, if she were a true daughter of that soil, should've raised that boy better than to become a latter-day Gradgrind...
By
Bryan Sentes, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
"Mr. Chiasson writes, "When a book sits next to the Internet, its authority as the final word on anything is automatically undermined," which he explains adroitly.
Is "its" the book or the internet? How does anything "sit next to the internet"?
Best Regards,
Don
By
Don, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
Chiasson insists on "sits" Donald.
I get it, and so should you.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
Brian,
"Books are real." and therefore cannot be used as a form of escapism? Is that your premise?
By
Dvelys, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
Dvelys:
You write: "Are we using books as an unhealthy escape from reality?" This question posits a distinction between books and reality, such that the former can be an escape from the latter. Of course I concur books can be escapist; I was merely calling to attention and into question the syntax of the question and the underlying logic it can be taken to imply, that books themselves are not a part of reality. I mean, if they're real themselves (which they undoubtedly are) how is it they can provide an escape from reality? The consequences of taking this question seriously, and I mean it seriously, not rhetorically, opens a curious speculative space....
By
Bryan Sentes, at Saturday, August 31, 2019
Brian, let me rephrase.
Based on the title of this post "Books and reading on the rise again but distractions still intrude"
My rhetoric is 'Can we attribute book reading as a distraction from life?'.
Sales of books are on the rise and no one bat's an eyelid. If however, alcohol consumption, playing video games, hours spent on social media, and the streaming of Netflix titles (etc) suddenly all increased at a global level then we would quickly attribute this to escapism.
By
Dvelys, at Sunday, September 01, 2019
Dvelys:
do I understand you are reacting to the word 'distractions' in the title of the post, equivocating on its meaning (distractions _from reading_) to another (distraction in general) to thereby pose your own question if books distract from non-bookish experience ("reality")?
If so, that equivocation, intentional or not, speaks, well, volumes....
By
Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, September 01, 2019
Dvelys: "Sales of books are on the rise and no one bat's an eyelid. If however, alcohol consumption, playing video games, hours spent on social media, and the streaming of Netflix titles (etc) suddenly all increased at a global level then we would quickly attribute this to escapism."
As far as reading for escapism, would that depend on the subject matter...the genre that one is reading?
Some of us read books for different reasons, self edification and for the pure pleasure of it. I'll make a broad statement of opinion that it is purely an individualistic endeavor.
By
Tim Hebert, at Sunday, September 01, 2019
Tim,
"As far as reading for escapism, would that depend on the subject matter...the genre that one is reading?
Some of us read books for different reasons, self edification and for the pure pleasure of it. I'll make a broad statement of opinion that it is purely an individualistic endeavor."
Agreed! Ultimately, we need to make a conscious effort to find balance.
By
Dvelys, at Sunday, September 01, 2019
Rich: "I get it, and so should you."
If I would, then I'd be like a ufologist. No thanks.
Best Regards,
Don
By
Don, at Monday, September 02, 2019
Hahaha Touche, Don
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Monday, September 02, 2019
Hey,
I finally read the article (I got The New Yorker digital subscription, 12 weeks for 6 dollars [!], now that sounds like a good deal). It certainly had good points.
Printed books surely has a great interface, that´s why it´s not going away. I don´t feel that printed books (at least not yet) are competing with internet or e-books (TV didn´t make movies or radio obsolete), they´re rather like different ways to access the same information (or something like that). I enjoy that I can check quickly things on internet and find articles, essays and photos of whatever it is that I´m currently interested in, but I would read books as printed ones, it´s much more nicer and easier, what a fuss it´s to read internet articles with your phone.
(Weird, almost all the poets the writer mentions are my favourites... Milton, Raymond Carver, Sylvia Plath, Emily Dickinson, John Clare...he even mentions one Tracy K. Smith poem and I´ve read her collection with that poem, which seems almost amazing coincidence. Great minds think alike?)
Well, anyway, looks like next 12 weeks I´ll be reading a lot of stuff from my computer. Thanks for the suggestion, I didn´t know The New Yorker was this interesting (or this cheap).
By
Jerry Cornelius, at Saturday, September 14, 2019
The New Yorker always has something interesting in each issue, then there are those cartoons.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Saturday, September 14, 2019
Rich,
absolutely, the Jonathan Franzen article about the climate change was very enjoyable, quite heavy stuff but wonderful. And yes, those cartoons are great too. (I can´t believe this digital subscription gives me an access to all their archives, I´m always waiting for a notification that tells me "you can´t read these stories, please subscripe for more" or something like that.) Actually, this could be the best 6 dollars I´ve ever spent...
By
Jerry Cornelius, at Saturday, September 14, 2019
Post a Comment
<< Home