UFO Conjectures

Sunday, November 24, 2019

The “myth” [UFOs] in the sky can’t save us

Copyright 2019, InterAmerica, Inc.

We, UFO enthusiasts, know that flying saucers/UFOs – strange portents above, in the sky (heavens) – always show up in dire times, societal woes.

During the Hebraic consternations in the B.C. eras, weird appearances seem to have been typical, if the Hebrew Bible is accurate to some degree.
Constantine’s vision near the end of Rome’s dominance as a Western world power is another instance.

The upheavals during the 1500s when the Church was challenged by outliers and reprobates, like Luther, portents appeared in the skies or in the minds of people distressed by the turmoil. (The Nuremberg and Basel newspaper “broadsheets” are the example.)
The end of creative, thoughtful endeavors at the end of the Nineteenth Century, as Jung has noted, brought forth the whimsy and sightings of alleged airships cavorting in the skies of America and elsewhere.

Then, after World War II, when civilization was beset by the possibility of nuclear annihilation, flying saucers and the idea of extraterrestrials appearing to humans and showing up in Earth’s skies became epidemic and remain somewhat pervasive even today when the ills of our civilization are not dynamic but intrusive at personal and societal levels.
The earnest desire of mankind to be salvaged by a God or gods rose up within the mind of primitive man, whose needs were more “existential” (in the current misuse of that word) than profound. (See Jaynes et al.)

And if there is, in reality, a God (or gods), they are silent and inconsequential – see Richard Friedman’s The Hidden Face of God.
Melville’s Moby Dick instills in us that God (Moby Dick) is quiescent, until it is provoked – sought for surcease or, in the case of Melville’s whalers, pursued. (Christians seeking something from God – via prayers or solicitations – will incur a notice from Him that is not good.)

Flying saucers/UFO, the new substitute for God, are just as hidden as Friedman’s God but not as malicious as Melville’s, thankfully.

But to keep hoping, as some readers here do, that UFOs will be the answer to their pathetic lives or society’s woes, is not only sad but madness.
It’s time to take UFOs in stride and accept the things as a phenomenon without gravitas or meaning, although I wish it were otherwise, but I am not fooled by the mythos or whatever it is that haunts some of us with its enigmatic flavor.

RR

29 Comments:

  • Who here expects UFOs to save them from anything other than boredom?

    "Christians seeking something from God – via prayers or solicitations – will incur a notice from Him hat is not good."

    This doesn't align with the countless testimonies about religious experiences associated with prayer. You've discussed Aquinas' visions on this blog before, which, in light of statements made on his deathbed, certainly don't seem to have challenged his view of God as good.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Mellville, Matty, like the Gnostics before him, had insights to the Divinity that we should, intellectually, respect.

    I know you want God to be "good" but the evidence speaks against that.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • But does the evidence really do that? https://philpapers.org/rec/HENSTU-5

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Yes, Matty. from the Garden of Eden, onward.....all the way to today.

    You know this.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Rich,

    Given the skepticism you've expressed about the ordinary concepts and thought systems we humans use to make sense of reality, including even logic itself, isn't your certainty about God's evil--rooted as it is in what seems to be the normal humane morality of modernized Western cultures--a bit strange?

    I don't agree, much less "know," that the evidence suggests that God isn't good. See the paper I linked.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Matty:

    I'm stuck with Aristotle's statement quoted by Aquinas in his Summa Theologica:

    Since Evil exists in the world, the Captain of the ship (God) has to be responsible.

    Thomas tried mightily to soften The Philosopher's position but wasn't able to.

    A sunrise view of civilization (yours) is enviable but naive and sweet, not based in an objective evaluation of history's anecdotes.

    I'll give your link a look but I'm firm in my view that God is either mad (insane) or just plain Evil in nature as Jung tells us in Answer to Job.

    Do I really need to pile up all the things on my side to make my point? I know you are more than well-read and know all the counterpoints to God's supposed goodness.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Rich,

    I'm not sure what you mean by "sunrise view of civilization." I think that, absent a good God (i.e. the real one), humanity's prospects are very bad. It's quite typical for Christians to think it's all downhill until Christ's return, no?

    There's no need to make the case for the evil of God. As you say, it's territory we're familiar with. What I objected to was your framing of matters as if your "evil God" position is obviously correct.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, November 24, 2019  

  • Matty:

    I've downloaded and read the paper you linked and after pouring over the first few pages, I find myself asking whether or not you've read my posts about philosophy.

    The twaddle you offer is a messy tour de force that doesn't apply to my arguments. I'm not an atheist, by a long shot, as most reading here know.

    The arguments presented in the paper do not apply.

    I suggest you gather yourself up -- shake off your need to over-compensate for your past atheistic stance -- and read materials that do apply to my position:

    The Structure of Evil by Ernest Becker [The Free Press/Macmillan, NY, 1968]

    Answer to Job by Carl Jung:

    [https://archive.org/stream/ThePortableJung/The%20Portable%20Jung_djvu.txt]

    I'm spouting Gnostic "theology" here. You have to read the Gnostic commentaries.

    I know you are well-read -- but not internet-read I hope.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, November 25, 2019  

  • Rich,

    You're being overly narrow in your reading of the paper, missing its broad import.

    Yes, Hendricks pursues his argument for the sake of rebutting atheists.

    But what are his atheist opponents drawing on? The existence of evil that, so their argument goes, shouldn't exist if the God of Christian theism is real, perhaps primarily because of His posited goodness. Your Gnostic approach takes up the same evidence of evil, but draws an "evil god" conclusion instead of an atheist one, because you operate from different background assumptions and knowledge than atheists. Nevertheless, your evidence for God's, what you'd say is a little-g god's, evil is just as easily undercut by Hendricks' response.

    I have no interest in revisiting Becker's work, which I've read and found useless--you know what I think of psychoanalytic theory. I have more respect for Jung but the flakey weirdness and wrongness of the psychoanalytic orientation of course pervades his thinking.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Monday, November 25, 2019  

  • Matty:

    Give the Answer to Job a read...especially the "conclusion" that God sacrificed Himself as atonement for the wrongdoings (the evils) He subjected His creation to.

    It's a fascinating, unique take on the death of Christ.

    You've read Schillebeeckx's two books on Jesus and Christ, yes?

    They also take us into theological nuances that over-ride the usual blather one finds all over the place.

    I can't list here, in comments, all the proclivities to Evil that God imposed on humans, directly, as noted in Biblical texts, and circumstantially in history.

    You are too hard on Freud (and Jung). both brilliant in many ways and flawed in a few other ways.

    You've read Moses and Monotheism, also I hope. And Jung's Red book too?

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, November 25, 2019  

  • "But to keep hoping, as some readers here do, that UFOs will be the answer to their pathetic lives or society’s woes, is not only sad but madness."

    I couldn't agree with you more, Rich. I do however find the "problem of evil" to be a comparatively weak argument. You might as well argue that the iron maiden torture device does not need an intelligent designer because anyone who could make such a device couldn't truly be a good person. Absurd, right?

    If it's the evil of the Christian God that you have an objection towards, at worst you’d have to give up the doctrine of biblical inerrancy and in doing so believe the Gnostic authors did not get every case right about God.

    There are a plethora of solid arguments against the "problem of evil". The strongest I find is that there is no explicit reason to think God and evil are incompatible. And no philosopher has ever been able to identify an implicit, hidden contradiction between the two. You can only make assumptions, but then the theist can also make an assumption as to why God acted immorally.

    Also, from the theist perspective, happiness is not God's main goal for humans, but knowledge of God Himself is. It is through suffering that humans can depend on God and strengthen their faith. Should you respond with anger and bitterness towards God or turn to Him in faith for strength to endure?

    As finite humans, we are not in a good position to assess the probability of whether God has morally sufficient reasons for the evils that occur and so I find "the problem of evil" to be a poor argument.

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Tuesday, November 26, 2019  

  • Dvelys, I couldn't agree more with your astute comments.

    There is a distinction that I keep forgetting to insert in my postings, one that I assume (wrongly), readers here know from my long-time ramblings.

    The Gnostics (and I, Jung, and maybe my pal Paul Kimball) believed that the God we and the Hebrews were contending with, Yahweh -- the god beneath God -- was Evil in essence [sic].

    The God above god is, for me, indifferent (or removed from general existence) but supreme. He can be accessed by rightful prayer and conduct, as some Saints showed us, and people like Aquinas et al. (the Cosmic Consciousness crowd), knew (or witnessed).

    Arguing here, I forget that some readers (Matty?) do not know my distinction, or Jung's.

    Is this the Christian God or Islamic God or the Buddhistic God?

    We are unable to determine as the god beneath God flummoxed humanity -- as the Gnostic say -- and we have been confused by that god's "divine" behavior.

    Melville's god is the Gnostic god I think. The "Evil god" is too.

    The "Almighty Spirit" -- as Klaatu said -- is the divinity we need to access, somehow.

    The problem for me in this discussion is that Matty and Daniel don't see my distinction, and so they argue from the standpoint that the Gnostic god and the supreme God are one and the same.

    The theology is interesting and has little to do -- it seems -- with UFOs but it can be made to be relevant.

    You almost slip into the god is evil or not category but might consider that your view about not knowing what (the) God has in mind is important to the discussion.

    God -- the Almighty Spirit -- is beyond human comprehension, that's certain. And as the Cabalists understood it, that's not the god the Hebrews were subject to.

    I hope we can get back on track with this, without offending the theological ne'er to wells who think such colloquies are useless. They aren't....they pertain.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, November 26, 2019  

  • Dvelys,

    It seems to me you accept some form of God belief. Are you a deist, theist, panentheist, or something else?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tuesday, November 26, 2019  

  • Matty,

    I'm ex-atheist, ex-Catholic, currently agnostic and believe there's a high probability that the universe is fine-tuned (due to scientific knowledge) which then requires a first cause. There's a possibility that I'd return to theism if I investigated and accepted the epistemology of religious disagreement (as our previous discussion) at a global and local level was not counter to theism. I do not doubt the accuracy of the historical records, but I have little tolerance for those within the Church.

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Tuesday, November 26, 2019  

  • Hi!

    I don´t think I´m at the moment ready for this kind of theological discussion (but please don´t stop), but...

    People used to believe in heaven and hell and aren´t our weird encounters still either in the sky (UFOs, lights, Mothman) or underground (lizard people encounters, cryptoterrestrials)? And while strange encounters or experiences happen right now and not in any other world, aren´t they usually connected with something in the heavens or in underground? When aliens abduct or examine someone, they may take the victim/experiencer/abductee for a little flight; scary creatures who appear come from the sky (Flatwoods monster?). Or then they appear in tunnels underground or disappear there (or something Richard Shaver -like, scary to think someone takes him seriously).

    Just a random thought: maybe God is insane and the universe is his straitjacket?

    By Blogger Jerry Cornelius, at Tuesday, November 26, 2019  

  • -> I'm ex-atheist, ex-Catholic, currently agnostic and believe there's a high probability that the universe is fine-tuned (due to scientific knowledge) which then requires a first cause.<-

    *

    Then, where did the seed of ALL life on earth, come from, if not from the Creator of this world!? The complexity of the DNA code to all life forms, that makes us what we are, in the food chain of survival..

    DNA; didn't happen by chance, there is an intelligence in it, and behind it, for Gods sake, is that not a clue!?..

    If one can believe in an [Intelligent Design] then one is, in my opinion, on the right road, to a positive outcome..

    You only need to ask, where did the complexity of DNA come from????..

    There is only one true God, and he is your creator.He himself says;" Adore no other god, but your creator" end of story..........

    By Blogger Daniel, at Wednesday, November 27, 2019  

  • It was mainly ontological arguments and the cosmological argument, coupled with the analytic Philosophy of Religion which moved me away from atheism.

    Daniel,

    For the record, these philosophical arguments do not prove that the Christian God exists, since there is no property of the Christian God used. There appears to be a huge gap between proving there is a first cause, and connecting that being to a Christian God or a God of any particular religion for that matter.

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Wednesday, November 27, 2019  

  • Dvelys:

    Maybe, you will find your answer, in "nature" it's all around you:)........

    By Blogger Daniel, at Thursday, November 28, 2019  

  • Electromagnetic transmissions, are all around you, through you, but you can't see them, hear them, or feel them, but they are there! What else is there,you haven't thought of?.........?

    By Blogger Daniel, at Thursday, November 28, 2019  

  • I've already mentioned the ontological/cosmological argument(s), and agree with you. Nevertheless, by no stretch of the imagination does that imply that Yahweh exists.

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Thursday, November 28, 2019  

  • Matty,

    Which one of the 40k+ do you belong to? 8-)

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Thursday, November 28, 2019  

  • Happy Thanksgiving, everyone (everyone celebrating, anyway). And especially to my friends Rich and Dvelys. I know I can get on your nerves, Rich, and indeed I can be a stubborn asshole, but I still love you and your blog!

    Dvelys is right: highly abstract arguments for God's existence, e.g. ontological arguments, don't offer a sufficient basis for Christian belief. Sufficient for generic theism, deism, etc. perhaps, but not Christianity, Judaism, Islam, or what have you.

    I'm undecided re: denomination, Dvelys. I'm drawn to the Orthodox Church and to traditional Catholicism (the direction of mainstream Catholicism, especially the revolting sex abuse nightmare, is beyond horrific).

    Also Dvelys, your remarks about the fine-tuning argument lead me to wonder if you're familiar with the brilliant work of astronomer Luke Barnes. He recently co-authored an excellent book on fine-tuning with an atheist or agnostic colleague (Barnes, a Christian, takes fine-tuning to offer evidence for God's existence).

    Here's the full PDF of the book, if you're interested: https://docdro.id/Oimesug.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Thursday, November 28, 2019  

  • Matty,

    I've now downloaded the PDF. Looks insightful! If I'm honest, the next step of intellectual integrity would be to postulate ways to counter the fine-tuning argument.

    Regarding church denomination, I've found 99% of Christians I've come across (in real life) base their faith on emotional reasoning. I've yet to converse with one who arrived at the "personal God" conclusion via intellectual propositions.

    The sexual crimes within the Catholic are probably the tip of the iceberg and the result of many epistemological disagreements. And yet the faithful continue to believe daily rosaries, abstaining from meat on Friday's, sitting through 1 hour of grim music, religious psychobabble and reciting the Nicene creed is the most efficient way to spend their relatively short-lived life.

    Rich, have we exhausted all of these paranormal topics? You seem to be on a hiatus.

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • Dvelys:

    I'm slipping in UFO stuff but I don't think you're browser is grabbing current postings from this blog.

    It seems to be locked on the one post you've responded to...this has happened to me in the past. I don't know what causes a browser to not provide current links, but here it is.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • Rich - I'm sure I saw a post tagged with Matty and me regarding quantum/simulation theory. Or was I mistaken?

    By Blogger Dvelys, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • That post was just for you and Matty, things to download.

    I deleted it because of its personal nature.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • Dvelys,

    Critiques of fine-tuning belief are very numerous. The Barnes and Lewis book is quite current and not at all tendentious--indeed, Lewis is inclined to the multiverse explanation (which seems to be the preferred position of atheists) whereas Barnes supports the theistic explanation, in which case the data of interest are reasonably understood to reflect "fine-tuning." Unsurprisingly, the theistic interpretation of fine-tuning has much going for it while not being so persuasive as to compel acceptance by all rational persons (this is almost always the case with substantive beliefs of a basically philosophical sort).

    With respect to your experience with religious believers, it's important to consider the fact that people can have good reasons for a view even if they lack the ability to articulate those reasons or defend them competently--they can have implicit reasons for their views, in other words, and those reasons can be good.

    My experience indicates that people very rarely have well-thought-out bases for their religious beliefs, whether they're atheists, Christians, or something else. Most of the atheists that I've interacted with just rattle off talking points that they barely understand, taken from some YouTuber or popular author, to defend their irreligiosity. On the other hand, I've known many thoughtful and highly intelligent Christians and atheists who could provide ample rational justification for their religious or irreligious commitments. In my own case, I only moved to Christianity from atheism because I acquired epistemic reasons that compelled me to do so. Of course, my religious life isn't just intellectual, but I wouldn't have the beliefs that I do if it weren't for rational considerations favoring them.

    Your statements about the Catholic sex abuse crisis confuse me. I have difficulty believing that child sex abuse is due to "epistemological disagreements"--I would blame psychological and moral defects on the part of those who commit such acts of abuse instead. I also find peculiar the notion of spending one's life "efficiently." It seems to reflect a utilitarian logic that Catholics would tend to--rightly, to my mind--reject as spiritually flattening and enervating. People in modernized societies often regard traditional ways of life as stodgy and repressive. And yet, within those societies, religious people are generally happier and more mentally healthy, and have a greater sense of meaning in life, than their irreligious counterparts--consider: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-319-52488-7. So while to the irreligious participation in religious practices may seem like a waste of time, when considered in some abstract way, it seems to me that, as is often the case, they are overly hasty in dismissing the possible value of ordinary human activities to promote their "enlightened" alternatives.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • Rich,

    Any chance that you can restore that deleted post? I didn't get a chance to retrieve everything in it.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

  • Matty/Dvelys:

    I found other material that I meant to include among the detritus in that post.

    I'll try and gather what pertains and provide it.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, December 03, 2019  

Post a Comment

<< Home