UFO Conjectures

Sunday, December 22, 2019

“You have to wonder … “

Copyright 2019, InterAmerica, Inc.

Again, the Ancient (Alien) Astronaut series on the History Channel provokes with its errant premise: Extraterrestrials have visited Earth and helped humans progress by teaching them all the things that make mental and physical evolution possible.

The problem is that the speculation is undercut by the reality, which is that all (and I mean all) the social/cultural peoples highlighted by the AA theorists are either extinct (Mayans, Incans, Eastern Islanders, Sumerians, Pharaohnic Egyptians, et al.) or never really developed into active, long-time (term) societal units (The Maori, the Aboriginals, the various AmerIndian tribes, et cetera).

That is, the societal units, given all the ET help that the AA people propose, never developed or maintained the special status that they were given by the alleged visitors from the skies.

Furthermore, most, if not all, the proponents of the idea that the gods mentioned in ancient texts were actual extraterrestrial visitors have now adopted the David Childress’ linguistic mantissa, “You have to wonder …”

Do we really have to wonder? About an idea that is so erroneous on the face of it that one can call those who propose it are delusional in ways that in the past would have got them incarcerated in an asylum.

Remember, that in logic if the premise is wrong, everything that follows is wrong.

I agree with visitor Daniel here that those choreographed rock formations all over the place are hard to ignore as feats of wonder and engineering facility unknown or even possible today.

But should the construction be attributed to extraterrestrial help or edification and not some other facility, like beings from the past or future or a part of humanity during the periods when such constructions took place? Just very capable, wise human beings?

(Even gods or Gods in the metaphysical sense that we humans have accepted up to the point of the AA propaganda?)

If extraterrestrials helped “primitive humans” with scaling rock formations and buildings of sublime constructions and then departed leaving those primitive humans to dissolve into a no longer extant race of people, can they (the ETs) be called truly advanced or helpful?

The premise is wrong. The Ancient Astronaut (Alien) crowd is wrong, and the rest of us do not “have to wonder.”
  
RR

22 Comments:

  • Ironic that the least "technologically" sophisticated peoples (e.g., the aboriginal Australians) can claim the longest continuous culture on the planet. That being said, China can make a strong claim to millennia of unruptured settled, complex, literate society...

    An interesting question might be why you seem to think alien intervention must entail cultural immortality. Just because a human society succumbs to entropy (as perhaps all have or do) doesn't imply that an earlier intervention by agents now absent is somehow less than technologically sufficient to have left its mark. (The relation between technical prowess and societal order is an interesting one here!).

    As a side question: would it be pedantic to remark that the Mayans and Incans, for example, are far from extinct? Their "high cultures" are no more (for various reasons: the Conquistadors had something to do with the demise of the Incan empire) but the peoples who inhabited those cultures are still with us, and even speak languages not unrelated to their ancestors'.

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • All the societies mentioned, Bryan, are not -- NOT -- flourishing cultures.

    This bespeaks, as I note that the so-called advanced visitors from the skies were rather deficient at providing a way forward to such flourishing.

    That the remnants of the human nature survives hardly speaks to what makes up a society; Neanderthal DNA remains intact but no one would write or say that the Neanderthalians are still a viable culture or society.

    You're just being obtuse and bizarrely academic Bryan.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Oh, c'mon--lighten up a little and read what you wrote and what I wrote and how I wrote it (tentatively, respectfully...)

    1. It's either ignorant or at worst racist to claim the Maori, Australian Aborigines, or various Turtle Island nations "never really developed into active, long-time (term) societal units" (_Is_ that in fact your claim?). All these cultures were old and complex when they encountered Europeans, and still persist (just ask 'em), despite the devastations of murderous colonialism; Australian Aborigines _can_ claim the oldest continuous culture on earth, with a cultural memory going back arguably 60,000 years, and that's ain't Childress hokum. Do you maintain Chinese civilization, too,"never really developed into active, long-time (term) societal units"? (I intentionally passed over in silence the racism that underwrites so much AA "theorizing" in this regard).

    2. Twice you remark the Mayans and Inca are "extinct": they aren't, even less so is Mayan culture so, for those in the know, however much the "high point" of their civilization has passed.

    3. Most importantly _my bizarre obtuseness was written in line and in support of your main point_. I very clearly--in line with your speculations--distinguished technical prowess from societal longevity, a distinction that hinges your critique.

    So, like, let's not go down that tired old road of dismissive insult and communicate respectfully and substantively, no?

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Why I am dismissive and "rude" buddy, is that you take my point into the weeds of academic foolishness.

    I didn't mention the Chinese societies or culture.

    And the AA shows I'm referencing appeared last night and took non-flourishing cultures and societies, one in Guatemala, and tried to say that ETs helped them.

    How? There is no proof of that and the indigenous peoples are as backward today as they were long ago.

    If ETs were helping them, they did a lousy job.

    Moreover, if the Mayan remnants are thriving, I'd like to know how.

    You keep taking a posting from its point to a place that has nothing to do with the postings intent or purpose.

    It's irritating.

    The thrust of my post, above, is that we don't need to wonder about what the AA people are proposing. It's nonsense from the get go.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • We can disagree without descending to throwing poop like caged monkeys, man.

    At the end of the day, I wrote to agree with you, and asides were indicated as such.

    You put your finger on an interesting point, the disjunction between technological prowess and social order and longevity.

    The AA theorist posit various cultural heroes (every settled culture has one, even China) are technologically-advanced aliens, who also taught the Egyptians, et al. engineering techniques that still baffle us today.

    Your criticism highlights that technical prowess doesn't entail social endurance. That disjunction is itself interesting. Moreover, it may be, as various SETI thinkers have proposed, that technological sophistication, such as our own, entails civilizational collapse, such as ours does, which explains why we have yet to detect other civilizations materially like our own, which also, as interestingly, undercuts the whole AA speculation...

    There remain many other assumptions and implications at work in the matter here, which I pass over in silence...

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • But we are monkeys, me more than you perhaps (okay, actually).

    My being aggrieved with you comes about when you take -- which is your wont -- a topic that is simple (as is my wont) and try to make it worthy of intellectual review, which I truly appreciate.

    But for this blog -- which seems to cater to lesser thinkers (my fault, of course) -- it's not a good thing to steep visitors and (sometimes) readers in the academic overlay you prefer and exemplify at your own blog.

    It just scares the dopes here and they withdraw into unstunned silence (which you offer yourself in the very understanding of my point with this comment).

    We (you and I) will not get any sensible response to our comments, especially yours which goes over the heads of everyone who comes here and even me most times.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • So be it. Back on the Index for me...

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • It'd be nice to see AA "theorists" do something to meaningfully justify their approach for once. Over and over they present us with "amazing," "inexplicable" creations of bygone civilizations that in fact already have perfectly adequate conventional explanations.

    They need to go back to basics, perhaps attempt a systematic inquiry into what the peoples of interest were actually capable of--it's even possible to estimate ancient people's cognitive abilities from bits of DNA in their skeletons now, research that I've personally been involved in. Of course, AA "theorists" won't bother with any of that, because they're dumb and only doing what they do to make money from the even dumber people who take their dreck seriously.

    Btw, Rich, Bryan isn't the only academic researcher who visits your blog (ahem), so it's false that his comments might as well be gibberish to "everyone" who reads this site.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Bryan, Matty, is an academic, unlike yourself, who is so ivory towerish that I have to try and take him down a lick or two now and then.

    He gets sidetracked by the most minor of comments by me, something so inconsequential to anything that I'm surprised it raises his academic hackles.

    He more often than not misses the forest for the trees.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Interesting somewhat!..

    Sooo, how does one; Cut, move, & lift into place, "humongous" stone blocks, estimated weight of some, 3-4000 tons,[Each] yes! 4000 tons, in a Siberian Mountain in Russa; that make up a stone wall, discovered some time back?? We can't do that today! So how was it done in the past?

    This is a far greater weight, than the 2300ton stone blocks in [Baalbek Lebanon]..

    And you Rich,say; ->the rest of us do not “have to wonder!?"<-

    The ETH does make sense, for an explanation, until something else can be proven otherwise..

    Past evidence, such as these stone walls,that can not be explained,do hold the key to something extraordinaire, going on in past history.

    IF, it's not the ETH..then who or what was it, that created these megalithic stone structures? Not humans!....But if so, WHO or WHAT, helped them?? .......?

    By Blogger Daniel, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Daniel...

    Who helped humans build those megastructures?

    First, who knows if humans built them?

    But if humans were encouraged or helped, maybe it was God or one of his Angels (Michael?) Or one of the Titans. Or Merlin. Or just a giant human subset that liked to built such things.

    You see, the constructures are open to a number of possibilities, not just ETs who have just disappeared or left no trace, but the rocks themselves, and moved on. Why?

    The AA theorists present their case -- a good one -- but only propagandistic, not scientific or logical.

    Your last query "WHO or WHAT, helped them??" is exactly on it....Who or What. What, indeed.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Daniel,

    Are you sure that these structures really *can't* be explained in conventional terms? It doesn't look like that's a certainty to me. For example: https://www.livescience.com/45285-how-egyptians-moved-pyramid-stones.html

    Of course, even if there is no possible conventional answer, Rich is completely right. It could've been any number of things apart from ETs: psychokinesis, supernatural agents, extinct races with incredible strength, etc. These answers hardly have anything less going for them than the AA bilge.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Rich:

    -> Your last query "WHO or WHAT, helped them??" is exactly on it....Who or What. What, indeed.<-

    *

    Well, this is my point Rich. The AA are suggesting ETs!!..

    But yes; -> if humans were encouraged or helped, maybe it was God or one of his Angels (Michael?) Or one of the Titans. Or Merlin. Or just a giant human subset that liked to built such things.<-..Yes that's possible..

    It's a mystery that bothers me, 3-4000tons! You see, it's like lifting 4000 motor cars
    all at once, in a time, supposedly, when there were no cranes or means to do so.

    Would the ropes or chains bust? or even if they had ropes & chains at all!? And what could or would, lift 4000tons at all, and move it, while suspended in midair!?

    Antigravity makes some sense, but now we're out on a limb, with the AA:)..........?

    By Blogger Daniel, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Rich, you’re the only person I know who can regularly bemoan the hoi polloi, then turn around and, without missing a beat, bemoan a Bryan Sentes for being too academic and ivory-towerish. You would have made a perfect politician! ;-)

    By Blogger Paul Kimball, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Yah, Paul....

    I'm a bastard. I like Bryan, we're pretty close.

    I think he's brilliant...too brilliant for his own good and for society, and surely for this blog.

    So I have to try and tame him, otherwise he'll ruin ufology. It can't handle his intellect.

    Like yours, it dilutes the mess or disorients it, and we can't have that, can we?

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, December 22, 2019  

  • Matty:

    Perhaps it's, that you don't appreciate what 4000tons are, to lift & move, in a time that is considered, prehistoric in contrast to our understanding of todays technological ability, to lift & move such tonage..4000tons is a mean task. The building of new ships come close, to that kind of weight,with todays technology, but how in a prehistoric past, could the lifting of such weights, be achieved??

    The AA trys to answer with due consideration, to a logical conclusion, that which, you call bilge.How do you & Rich, know their proposal is not correct.You don't!! Neither of you.But these stone megaliths, are in place, for all to see,as proof of their existence. 4000 ton,stone blocks in a Siberian Mountain in Russa; and 2300ton stone blocks in [Baalbek Lebanon]..How did they do that, in their time,who ever they are,the AA is only saying, they must have had help,to lift and to move.Who would likely have that power??..exactly!!..The AA make an interesting point, right!?..........

    By Blogger Daniel, at Monday, December 23, 2019  

  • Daniel,

    I'll let Matty provide an answer but my point is that the stone walls are intriguing, in their construction and aesthetic deployment (how nicely they fit together).

    But how was that achieved? You accept the AA theorist's view that extraterrestrials provided the help or ability to create such megalithic wonders.

    Did they bring equipment in their motherships that could be used? Or did they have some special ability (or facility) to do such things without the need of equipment?

    If it's the latter, is it possible that humans could have had such ability also? A mental procedure that could raise (lift) such stones, having moved them to the sites where they are found in the same way? Does it have to be an ET ability?

    You and the AA crowd present, at least, two premises: ETs were the progenitors of the stone wall idea and had the ability to construct such walls. (Or they relieved humans of their repressed ability to do such things -- levitate huge rocks -- and instructed these primitive peoples how to free up or use that up-to-then forgotten or suppressed ability.)

    And from my commentary here, in answer to Bryan Sentes, this special ability didn't help such peoples survive their eventual denouement: Easter Islanders, Olmecs, Mayans, Incans, Sumerians, Indians -- of all kinds -- et al.

    It seems that building rock structures was the best thing that your ETs could offer or provide. Building a permanent civilization or society wasn't in the cards, apparently.

    These are a few of the flaws in AA thinking.

    Something special created those megalithic wonders, but it wasn't an ET procedure.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, December 23, 2019  

  • Rich:

    -> And from my commentary here, in answer to Bryan Sentes, this special ability didn't help such peoples survive their eventual denouement: Easter Islanders, Olmecs, Mayans, Incans, Sumerians, Indians -- of all kinds -- et al.<-

    *

    Over time that has gone by, many major disasters have taken place on earth; Earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanoes, fire, famine & war,have taken its toll, with loss of life, & destruction, leaving what's left, in the way of megastructures etc. to mill-over in aw & amazement,and it is still going on, to this day, just look what happened in Japan, with the earthquake & tsunami!?...IF there is a total loss of life, memory is lost as well,and all that is left, is only that which survives the disaster, in the sands of time........

    By Blogger Daniel, at Monday, December 23, 2019  

  • Daniel,

    I'm not an archaeologist, and if these structures indeed turn out to be anomalous, I'd be happy to have another oddity on record that should bedevil "skeptics." I'd probably be inclined to a paranormal rather than ET explanation of them in that event, because I'm quite confident that the paranormal is real (consider the work in parapsychology and psychical research), whereas I have little reason to believe in ET intervention in human affairs.

    The point Rich and I are making (hope I've understood you correctly, Rich) is that the AAs haven't really made their case. They jump from (alleged) anomaly to aliens, when they have nothing to properly justify that inference.

    I have no real knowledge of the Lebanon and Russia cases. Can you provide more information, please? Maybe some links? If they really are inexplicable, I'd be fascinated to learn about them. But every time I look into one of these alleged archaeological enigmas, it seems they aren't too mysterious. This is why I asked if you really are sure that the structures you mention are anomalous.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Monday, December 23, 2019  

  • Matty:

    Links to: Ballbek (Lebanon) https://www.pinterest.nz/mrv787/baalbek-lebanon/

    http://www.ancient-wisdom.com/lebanonbaalbek.htm

    *

    Link to: Huge 3-4000ton stone blocks, in Russia..

    https://mysteriousuniverse.org/2014/02/super-megalithic-site-found-in-russia-natural-or-man-made/

    *

    Matty, this link to the 3-4000ton stone blocks, is not the one I have in my PC with photo (I'm still looking) but this link is in the same area, and as you can see, they are huge:) The point being however, is; did man put these in place? I doubt it very much, as you can see for yourself.........

    By Blogger Daniel, at Monday, December 23, 2019  

  • Thanks, Daniel. Merry Christmas to you.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tuesday, December 24, 2019  

  • And Merry Christmas to you, Matty......

    By Blogger Daniel, at Tuesday, December 24, 2019  

Post a Comment

<< Home