Jacques Vallee: Off his game or spot on?
When I write that I think the eminent Jacques Vallee may be “senile,” I’m being facetious.
(Senility is now assigned to the dementia category, and no longer accepted as a correct designation for loss of memory and other mental malfeasances of the aged.)
What I’m saying about Vallee is that he is no longer functioning in the full bloom of his former intellectual ability, and most of you have seen the diminution; it’s blatant in his current, new book Trinity.
The absence of acute intellectualism derives from Jacque’s sliding into sentimental asides – very unscientific, obviously (and rife for psychological conjecture) along with his rumination on the natural beauty of the area in which he finds himself, not the specific area where the alleged craft he’s investigating is but the adjunct area where the first Atom Bomb tests took place.
This is a diversion that beclouds what he’s doing in the area – a vacation-like account that would better fit a travel magazine or personal diary, not a scientific sojourn meant to show that a weird object with attendant creatures in it, the “object” having a disastrous accident, that Vallee and his co-author (Paola Harris) think is an event opening humanity here to a vivid and important impactive episode.
My point? The book is a travelogue and fictive-like rumination, full of emotional clutter and side-bars that are not pertinent to a premise of proving a “UFO” or something akin crashed in 1945, in the Southwest, a few years before the infamous Roswell incident.
Dominick thinks that Vallee is writing within a context of child reminiscence, which may be correct but that’s not a scientific providence, unless you’re writing about an episode that’s psychoanalytic in nature.
To surround his thesis – that a craft from outside Earth’s provenance crashed in 1945 and was witnessed by two young boys (who supposedly pilfered some elements from the disastrous event) – with acute hints that the kids were prescient for their ages, 7 and 9, is a flawed scientific enterprise; it’s a set-up for a movie script, which may be what the book is really about.
At any rate, the book is novelistic, not scientific or pertinent to UFO history. It’s the attempt by an old man, grabbing at is lost youth (perhaps) or a last gasp at fame, which Dominick, to his credit, notes.
N.B. Photo of Vallee (above) from new dimensions radio
RR

4 Comments:
Relevance is the coin of realm in ufology, since there's really nothing else to preen about. If you're a believer, you've got the obvious baggage of decades worth of loony-tunes tales and scattered data that adds up to what? If you're a debunker or skeptic, maybe God will forgive you someday, but if you expect to convince anyone of your own slanted views, well, aren't we precious. Everyone, it seems, lives for making points rather than reaching the end game, and the road to that remains littered with Vallees and green pyramids and empty desert skies.
This actually comes out meaner-spirited than I first intended, but, oh well. Aren't we all entitled to be a little miffed after what we've been through, then and now?
By
Ron, at Wednesday, May 26, 2021
Yes, Ron...
It's quite okay to be miffed by what we've been subjected to about something we're justifiably interested in.
You weren't mean-spirited. Now take my screeds; those are mean, and not just in spirit.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, May 26, 2021
It's worth mentioning that cognitive decline is a normal part of aging. Probably as inevitable as aging itself. So it's pretty well certain that Vallee is not at the level he was on decades ago.
I can only agree with RR's assessment. The 1945 saucer crash tale is presented in a Chris Rutkowski book (don't recall the title) where I encountered it years ago. I thought it was ridiculous at the time. I didn't ever expect that such a clearly goofy story would be thought worthy of book-length treatment by Jacques Vallee.
Martin
By
Martin Black, at Wednesday, May 26, 2021
Vallee, Martin, references a number of previous accounts of the supposed event, not the books but the efforts at research.
I think Vallee and Harris's plan is for a movie...via James Fox?
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, May 26, 2021
Post a Comment
<< Home