What does Researching mean?
Copyright 2022, InterAmerica, Inc.
Our buddy Ron likes Michael Swords, as do I, and Ron likens
Michael to a “researcher.”
I have to disagree pretty much. Michael Swords writes excep- tionally well but is he doing actual research?
Is anyone?
Research means going to a place where UFOs were said to land or appeared to affect the environment. Measurements of specific kinds should be undertaken and recorded.
Witnesses need to be queried and tested perhaps for anything that might have affected their biology or whether they are in a normal state: sober, without drugs in their bodies, what foods they ate within the time frame of their observation or experience, mental condition before (and after) their experience, et cetera.
Other witnesses need to be located and tested, and other occur- rences within the time-frame need to be found if any are suspected.
The geographical area needs to be checked for any anomalies, natural or unnatural, weather conditions also.
Similar events need to be located, in the time-frame and his- torically checked.
For photographs or alleged “debris” the latest technology and analytics need to be employed coupled by some of the same activity as enumerated above.
Some pretend researchers like to say they’re gathering data, which is not what real researchers do.
Data is overt information that plugs into or has some connection to the thing (the phenomenon) being studied. This is supplemented by more ephemeral material that hovers in the vicinity of the thing (phenomenon) under scrutiny.
Data is tangible; ephemera isn’t but is integral to real research methodologies.
Research is a gathering of all information available and pertinent to that which is being studied.
Is reading a paper about UFOs research? Certainly not. Are con- versations with witnesses or participants to a UFO sighting or event research? Only if it is thorough and detailed, covering all possible relevant details, some of which are noted above.
Are so-called UFO researchers actually researchers? No. They are pretenders adopting the tag, researcher. Because it gives them cachet, false cachet but cachet of a kind.
Is Professor Swords a researcher? Not quite. Are persons who write about UFOs or the paranormal researchers? Only if they engage in the kinds of activity mentioned above.
I have to disagree pretty much. Michael Swords writes excep- tionally well but is he doing actual research?
Is anyone?
Research means going to a place where UFOs were said to land or appeared to affect the environment. Measurements of specific kinds should be undertaken and recorded.
Witnesses need to be queried and tested perhaps for anything that might have affected their biology or whether they are in a normal state: sober, without drugs in their bodies, what foods they ate within the time frame of their observation or experience, mental condition before (and after) their experience, et cetera.
Other witnesses need to be located and tested, and other occur- rences within the time-frame need to be found if any are suspected.
The geographical area needs to be checked for any anomalies, natural or unnatural, weather conditions also.
Similar events need to be located, in the time-frame and his- torically checked.
For photographs or alleged “debris” the latest technology and analytics need to be employed coupled by some of the same activity as enumerated above.
Some pretend researchers like to say they’re gathering data, which is not what real researchers do.
Data is overt information that plugs into or has some connection to the thing (the phenomenon) being studied. This is supplemented by more ephemeral material that hovers in the vicinity of the thing (phenomenon) under scrutiny.
Data is tangible; ephemera isn’t but is integral to real research methodologies.
Research is a gathering of all information available and pertinent to that which is being studied.
Is reading a paper about UFOs research? Certainly not. Are con- versations with witnesses or participants to a UFO sighting or event research? Only if it is thorough and detailed, covering all possible relevant details, some of which are noted above.
Are so-called UFO researchers actually researchers? No. They are pretenders adopting the tag, researcher. Because it gives them cachet, false cachet but cachet of a kind.
Is Professor Swords a researcher? Not quite. Are persons who write about UFOs or the paranormal researchers? Only if they engage in the kinds of activity mentioned above.
Is there real research going on with the UFO phenomenon? Inside some “secret” venue but not in the UFO community itself. Not even rarely.
The Craft of Research [Fourth Edition] by Booth, Colomb, Williams. Bizup. And Fitzgerald [The University of Chicago Press, 2016 to date] has been elucidated at this blog before and remains a concise primer of what constitutes research.
Try getting your hands on a copy so you aren’t wowed by pretenders.
(Image atop from QuestionPro)
RR
RR

8 Comments:
Excellent, Rich, and I endorse your views entirely. As I recall, some of the early UFO organizations (APRO, NICAP, maybe MUFON) did some of this by employing specialist/volunteers who would actually visit UFO sites, take measurements, prepare reports, etc. It was research but with a very small "r". In Ruppelt's book it's clear that even early Blue Book did some of this. And if our government is really interested in the phenomenon, you would assume that that has continued somewhat. But where all of the research evidence resides--and how to get our grubby hands on it--is anyone's guess.
By
Dominick, at Monday, November 28, 2022
I fear that UFO/UAP "research" is permanently stuck in the methodology level of those ghost hunter folks we stumble across on cable TV from time to time, two or three hobbyists with their recorders and camera equipment bumbling around in a supposedly haunted house in the dark squeaking out "What's that noise? What's that smell?" on and off during the night. This silliness is compounded by an ancient and inexplicable phenomena that apparently operates well outside the bounds of what we would label as The Laws Of Physics. How exactly are we to research a veritable tsunami of will o' the wisp trickster events that have been bedeviling mankind forever, especially when one faction is very protective of the whole "It's gotta be outer space guys!" theory of what the heck seems to be going on.
The ET hypothesis is comforting because it means that we have skin in the game, that we can "catch up" technologically to these outer space guys and beat them at their own game because, hey, we are technological too! Any other alternative means that we will probably never ever figure any of this out or...even worse...that something unfathomable and maybe even malevolent just might be happening and we can't do a thing about it...
By
Zeke The Poltroon, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Really appreciate your perspective Zeke. We may well be dealing with something we just are not able to comprehend.
Let me argue, however, that the phenomena hardly "operates well outside the bounds of what we would lable as The Laws of Physics." It may stretch those bounds somewhat but I don't see its many manifestations as necessarily "well outside" the bounds. After all, we are still in the early stages of discovering what those very bounds are in the first place.
I've come to this conclusion because despite all of the Woo, Woo, associated with Ufos, the phenomena still appears in many cases material and "technological". It appears to have a solid structure; appears to fly, stop, and accelerate, at least somewhat like our own advanced technology; is often associated with EMP effects (car stoppings, etc.); often has lights; can leave counter-clockwise swirls in grass where the grass lives but never grows back up; can appear to be "evasive" when confronted with our planes or radar.
You get the point. Some of us are still slightly ET oriented simply because most of what we see (with respect to UFOs) resembles, at least in part, some advanced technology. Even abductions (which I have the most trouble with) can fit since we know that humans occassionally snatch other humans and animals and plants for study...or just for research or, sadly for fun. So let's not give up on "research" since it may yet give us an important piece of the puzzle...
By
Dominick, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Rich, I tend to agree with your assertions. A while back, when I was actively interested in the subject matter, I fancied myself as that of an "analyst", analyzing components of the alleged claim based on past expertise in various professions. But, in the end I only rendered an opinion which one could accept or reject.
By
Tim Hebert, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Good points all, Dom, and wise advice to not give up on the concept of research. Also pardon my overly-hyperbolic use of the phrase "outside the bounds of what we would label as The Laws Of Physics." I guess in my own theatrical way I am ineptly trying to make the point that what we, in a technological culture raised on the likes of Star Trek, War Of The Worlds, and The Day The Earth Stood Still, are more than likely going to interpret UFOs as corporeal beings piloting advanced craft from their planet to ours. In the say, the 14th century, though, the very same kind of odd things were happening to people, only their non-technological cultures, in my humble opinion, interpreted these events as the mischievous doings of fairies, gremlins, demons and the like--little "men" cavorting around doing odd things and speaking in riddles, burning circles in the grass where the strange little dudes were seen, people being taken away then returned with major time loss,etc. Tricksters like this have been a part of the human experience from time immemorial only now we see them as The Space Brothers hopefully here to save us maybe?
By
Zeke The Poltroon, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Tim. I could accept the title of analyst for those who have taken a serious look at the phenomenon.
Maybe we can get a few people to use the sobriquet for their efforts.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Monday, November 28, 2022
RR,
I don't think we should leave out John Greenewald and his efforts with his "Black Vault" effort.
BD
By
Bryan Daum, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Point taken.
By
Ron, at Monday, November 28, 2022
Post a Comment
<< Home