The Zero-Sum Game in Ufology
As a reviewer, Barbara Graziosi, defined in a London Review
of Books piece for the July 26th, 2016 issue, about Tim Whitmarsh’s
book, Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World, the zero-sum game
is:
… “if I am right, you are wrong.” [Page 32]
Of course, the zero-sum game is a little more complex than
that, as Wikipedia provides:
But for my purposes, Ms. Graziosi’s definition fits the
zero-sum game as I see it; applicable to ufology and for the UFO community in
toto.
In ufology, there are UFO believers, skeptics, agnostics,
atheists, and a rather apathetic horde.
But within the debate milieu the back-and-forths come
down to “as I am right, you have to be wrong.”
But that is non-intellectual, not academic, and illogical,
especially when it comes to a bona fide enigma, such as UFOs or flying
saucers.
When it comes to UFOs, there is no right or wrong; there
never has been a right or wrong.
Even the Roswell incident remains controversial and
unsettled. (Go to Kevin Randle’s blog for an example: kevinrandle.blogspot.com)
To take a hard-core skeptical position, like that of Zoam
Chomsky, is rather irrational, stifling dialogue and a wholesome debate about
the issues that the phenomenon provokes.
The book mentioned upfront here deals with theogony, the
genealogy of god myths, which is pertinent to ufology, the genealogy of flying
saucer myths.
But the zero-sum game distorts discussion, and creates
mind-sets.
We, in the UFO community, don’t need a détente, but we do
need an open environment where the pros and cons can be discussed without the
taint of bias.
That’s a utopian desire, mostly because ufologists and UFO
buffs, generally, are an uneducated lot, remiss in the humanities, certainly,
and devoid of erudition in logic and philosophical methodology, as real UFO
researcher Richard Hall instilled in me long ago.
Let’s hope the zero-sum game is suppressed, or dismissed
altogether.
RR


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home