Jonah in the whale (or into something)
Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.
This cartoon, in the April 16, 2018 New Yorker,
sent me to my Catholic BIBLE to read the Jonah in the whale account, in
my BIBLE as Jonas, in a two page chapter by that name, and the “thing”
Jonas ended up in called “a great fish.”
If I recall correctly, some ancient astronaut “theorists”
claim that Jonah (Jonas) found himself in an alien submersible, communicating,
not with God, but extraterrestrials.
The suggestion is interesting but let’s try another
approach.
Reading Jonah’s adventure in Chapter Three, where he
prophesied in Nineveh (Ninive) that the inhabitants and that Assyrian capital
itself were about to be destroyed by God because of their evil ways.
But the leaders and inhabitants of the capital repented in
various ways, believing that God would relent, which God did, diminishing
Jonah’s prophecy and Jonah himself, God explaining to Jonah, who was heavily
troubled by seeming to be a false prophet, that the great city, with thousands
of inhabitants, who had repented, were worthy of salvation despite Jonah’s
pique.
So, let’s go back to the “great fish” episode.
Jonah, who had been thrown overboard, at his own request, by
the crew of the ship he was on and which was in a maelstrom, found himself
inside “the belly of hell” (he said) from which he called out to God for mercy.
This wasn’t a call to an alien presence but, rather, a plea
from despair, by a man who was psychologically “at sea” (as psychiatrists might
put it).
There was no “whale” or ET submersible.
And is this an indication of what some UFO witnesses
(Betty/Barney Hill, Hickson/Parker, Travis Walton, Robert Taylor, et al.)
experienced: a “nervous breakdown” as fiction has it, a psychological trauma?
Almost all UFO encounters can be explained by the
psychiatric (or neurological) “science(s).”
RR


9 Comments:
If by "encounter" you mean "experiencing entities" or claiming an abduction (and those are the type of events you cite) I am inclined to agree. But a broader meaning of the word "encounter" would include hundreds (perhaps thousands) of incidents (even that recent Pentagon revelation encounter)...and I most certainly would NOT agree. In those cases I still believe that we are dealing with something entirely physical and as yet unexplained.
By
Dominick, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
Dominick:
I would go so far as to say that many UFO encounters (sightings), without entities, are psychologically induced, not all but many.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
My claim about "physical" could be substantiated by photos, film strips, ground based and air radar, physical trace cases, radar returns plus visual, etc. Not perfect substantiation by any means (a crashed or captured UFO would be perfect substantiation) but "probable" substantiation that we are likely dealing with something ("thing) physical. I'm curious, Rich. How would you support your claim that many (not all) sightings are psychologically induced? What evidence would or could you provide to convince a non-believer? Even arguing that some UFO reports are made by dim wits or individuals that are not playing with a full deck, such a person might still be reporting something that coincides with an objective physical object as yet undetermined. So that gets us, you actually, exactly nowhere.
By
Dominick, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
You know, Dominick...
That I believe persons report what they see, rather accurately. They, indeed, see what they say they saw. But it is their reality, not necessarily ours or the real reality, a topic addressed here often, ad nauseum.
As for videos, imprints on the ground, et cetera, you do recall the Ted Serios nonsense of a few (many) years ago, yes?:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Serios
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
Sure, I recall the Serios nonsense. But it was just that, nonsense, yes? Is the Pentagon video (and you must know that there are hundreds of gun camera videos) nonsense in the same sense? Clearly not. Or the Newhouse filmstrip? Or the radar/visual events in Belgium in the early 1990s? Serios was a con man but the Navy pilots who observed and filmed a UFO are not con men nor are they delusional.
By
Dominick, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
But Dominick...
What are the gun camera's showing, or any Pentagon video?
The Belgium wave?
You offer a thing -- apparently physical (real, tangible) -- afflicting the senses or technology.
What reality is accosting us? Each individual's? Or something more?
What's your view, your opinion?
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
As readers can see, Dominick and I have gone into the weeds, neither addressing the idea that Jonah wasn't really in a whale (or great fish) nor in an ET submersible.
Dominick wants to confirm that his UFOs are tangible somethings and I wish to dissuade him of that notion, somewhat.
We are not on topic, really....because we UFO "nuts" are not good thinkers.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
I, of course, disagree completely with that. You and I are both "good thinkers." We have gone "into the weeds" so to speak because it is totally pointless to debate whether Jonah was or was not in any whale; but not totally pointless to debate whether UFOs are real, physical objects (whose nature is as yet undetermined) or purely metaphysical or psychological phenomena. That's an important question that good thinkers can debate. The other is pure speculation best left to those where reason is clearly a secondary consideration.
By
Dominick, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
No, Dominick...
We strayed into the bushes, far from the topic.
It's my fault. I indulge you as you are serious about what UFOs are (or are not).
I'll have more to say about "bad" (errant) thinking in the UFO community, upcoming.
(And it doesn't involve you or me.)
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Sunday, April 15, 2018
Post a Comment
<< Home