UFO Conjectures

Sunday, August 19, 2018

Bryan Sentes, Persinger, and Crackpottery

Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.

My pal Bryan Sentes has a piece, at his blog, on the passing of Michael Persinger, a researcher that my buddy (now deceased) Bruce Duensing (may he rest in peace also, like Mr. Persinger) lauded in his blog many times.

I’m presenting a few excerpts here from Bryan’s Persinger salute; excerpts about electro-magnetics that Mr. Persinger was obsessed by and studied extensively:

“What is compelling, though, is the way his research suggests that the Earth herself might be imagined to communicate with human beings via EM phenomena.

“That Contactees and Abductees both have received warnings concerning environmental catastrophe segues nicely with the notion that the Earth articulates her concerns via tectonic energies and an available image reservoir, whether a Collective Unconscious or not. That Earth itself transmits EM energies at 30-33 Hz (an instance of a numerological pattern that runs through the whole mythos) and that these transmissions are called Extra-low Frequency (ELF) waves is also poetically suggestive, especially in view of the links made to Faery lore and the UFO mythology by, among others, Jacques Vallee….”

I love Bryan Sentes, as he (and others) well know, but Bryan is absorbed by what I call crackpottery, theories and thinking from great, intelligent humans that border on madness.

(Bryan got me enthused by the Eleusis mysteries to the point that I ordered a book yesterday about the crazy mysteries, before I saw in Amazon that Aleister Crowley and The Rosicrucians also were absorbed by the alleged use of psychedelics that many Greek philosophers used to enhance their thinking. Crowley and The Rosicrucians? Give me an intellectual break!)

Bryan’s enthusiasm for “far-out” ideas is troubling for me, as his is one of the finest brains writing about UFOs today.

And his UFO commentary is moderated by his brilliance and caution to be lucid and logical.

Yet, he sure likes to insert names and ideas from the fringe of thought, and support those ideas with a bountiful amount of examples and data that give credence to them.

And this he is doing with Persinger’s views.

I’ve watched Persinger videos off and on and took in his experimental methodology with hesitancy as Persinger tapped in to the electromagnetism that surrounds the Earth and impacts human beings.

My cautions come from Persinger’s use of equipment that measures electromagnetism but doesn’t ensure that the equipment is not compromised by the very thing it is supposed to be measuring.

Like psychedelics ad other hallucinogens that alter brain waves, Bryan thinks that electromagnetism, much as Tesla thought too, is integral to human kind, the Earth, and living matter; it’s Ancient Astronaut kind of thinking.

And it may have some validity, which Bryan is sure to find in some esoteric or arcane works.

But such theorizing, as my friend Bruce Duensing loved, is as close to madness as possible without being psychotic.

It strays from the Descartian reality to the boundaries of Foucaultian madness that permeates minds with too much upon them, causing descent from common sense.

Bryan offers, at his blog, that he will be providing thoughtful sustenance to Persinger’s ideas and his own about those ideas.

I can barely wait….as I am absolutely enchanted by the waywardness of human thought.

RR

16 Comments:

  • Hm. Thanks for the attention--no press is bad press, and all--but it seems you read my last post a little too hastily.

    1. N.b. the "though" in the first sentence of the passage you quote. It refers back to the fact that Persinger's research touches on the being or reality or nature of the UFO phenomenon, not its meaning, which is my concern, the UFO mythos as a spontaneously poetic material, a point I make in the paragraph immediately preceding the cited passage. The speculations in the passage you quote are more _poetic_ inferences than cognitive ones.

    2. That you and others have concerns about Persinger's research is granted; I look forward to looking into it in more detail, too. That being said, those of the ten blog posts of Persinger's that reply to his critics re his God Helmet likely answer the concerns you raise here.

    3. How you can state that "electromagnetism, much as Tesla thought too, is integral to human kind, the Earth, and living matter [is] Ancient Astronaut kind of thinking" boggles my mind. The WHO and other very sobre, solid institutions have conducted and continue to research the effects of EM radiation on the human body and other organisms. Put "electromagnetic radiation biological effects" into Google Scholar, and you get 426,000 results...

    That being said, in what I'm up to, fringe, esoteric, and arcane works, etc. are all material for _the poetic imagination_. Nothing human is alien to _it_! My job is to weave it together in a kind of pseudo-persuasive, 'Pataphysical manner.

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, August 19, 2018  

  • You make your points more than well, Bryan and they are precious.

    I hope others check out your blog for your UFO commentary. They will be enlightened.

    You mentioned, privately, some concern for my citing Crowley and The Rosicrucians.

    But here are the blurbs from Amazon that made me insert those two blathering entities:

    "This issue of the Rosicrucian Digest presents a compendium of materials that provide a solid introduction to the most important aspects of the Eleusinian Mysteries.

    "The Rites of Eleusis Kindle Edition by Aleister Crowley (Author)"

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, August 19, 2018  

  • But, brother, just because Crowley and the pseudo-Rosicrucians took interest in the Mysteries doesn't mean they held the same thesis Wasson et al. do; the mindless Amazon bot just recommended these other volumes because they deal with the same topic, the Eleusinian Mysteries... And, as I noted in the same correspondence, Crowley was dead before news of LSD-25 even made it out into the world; and magic mushrooms weren't made public until the '50s.

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Sunday, August 19, 2018  

  • My point, as muddled as it may be, is that addled minds find the Eleusis mysteries enticing.

    I'm not questioning the Wasson and comrades thesis as the book I ordered hasn't come yet.

    I'm sure the contributors to the ordered book are scholars of an edifying kind.

    But mysteries of a kind remind me of conspiratorial theses, which need a complete vetting, the operative word being "complete."

    And since the philosophers addressed in the book as users of a kind of mind-altering substances don't admit to such or acknowledge its use and/or efficacy, the matter is iffy for me.

    You seem willing to accept that the Eleusis mysteries tell of a significant methodology for enhancing thought.

    I see such wish-fulfilling enterprises in need of Freudian analysis.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Sunday, August 19, 2018  

  • 1. I fail to see how the fact that _some_ "addled minds find X interesting" implies all minds who find X interesting are addled. You seem to withdraw that implication in your next comment, but also seem to want to have it both ways.

    2. I fail to understand what you mean by mysteries of a kind like conspiratorial theses needing a vetting: that those who develop theories about such mysteries need be completely vetted? Like in 1), you're flirting with an ad hominem argument.

    3. The authors of the book in question are G. Gordon Wasson, Albert Hofmann, and Carl A. P. Ruck. Wasson was, among other things, an amateur ethnomycologist, who helped rediscover "magic mushrooms" and played a role in identifying their psychoactive molecule; he was never covert about his experience. Hofmann, a chemist, is well-known as the first to synthesize LSD-25 and experience a "trip"; he was very open about his various uses of LSD. Ruck was a classical philologist; I don't know about his use of entheogens. All that being said, there is no empirical evidence the respectful use of entheogens impairs cognitive ability in the way you seem to think. In fact, _experiments_ have been conducted in their value in problem-solving (results were positive). Again, you're deploying an ad hominem, here, based on a lie (that the authors used entheogens and neither admitted it nor "acknowledged [their] use or efficacy" (which I don't pretend to understand)). By the way, "mind-altering substances" range from oxygen to DMT; unless you're going to dismiss runners, meditators, and even tea-teetotalers and coffee drinkers, you'd need refine the terms of your dismissal here.

    3. And, to clarify: I do _not_ "accept that the Eleusis mysteries tell of a significant methodology for enhancing thought". I remark only that a very careful case has been made that the Eleusinian Mysteries included entheogenic use; initiates included Plato, Aristotle, and the great tragedians. One might infer a link between the use of entheogens and Plato's Theory of Ideas, given an analogy between the kind of ideation entheogens can give rise to (it's in the scholarly literature).

    4. I see the stubborn resistance to such ideas, on the basis of fallacious argument and lack of hard facts in need of logical criticism (!).

    At any rate, let's see what you think about Wasson et al.'s case....

    [and for folks reading over the shoulder of this exchange, it goes back to a backnforth concerning psychedelics and the UFO experience, and RR's Thomistic ethical reservations about their use].

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • I may have to get that Diogenes Laerius book I posted about in July.

    He might enlighten me about the private exploits of great philosophers inclined to use "dope" to help their thinking.

    I await the Eleusis book with intellectual anticipation.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • I doubt you'll find any mention of "dope" in DL.

    Who's arguing any great philosophers used any "to help their thinking"?

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • Why else would they use it, for recreation? Geez.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • What was imbibed at the Eleusinian Mysteries was a sacrament, brother, not some prototype smart drug...

    (And I just read of an argument that Socrates was condemned to death because of his abuse of said sacrament, but I gotta follow that up more closely...)

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • I thought you might come back with the sacrament explanation and I agree that makes sense.

    The great Socrates is forever chastised for something.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • Chris Rutkowski, Canada's sensible ufologist, craps all over Persinger's work:

    https://uforum.blogspot.com/2018/08/the-passing-of-michael-persinger.html

    By Blogger Terry the Censor, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • And I am a Rutkowski fanboy, as you know Terry.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • Terry:

    The Daily Grail obit links to Rutkowski's 1984 "crapping" as well as two rebuttals from Persinger posted in 2015.

    But, again, my concern is not so much with facts as the truth, as it were, but I'd have to review that very long Rutkowski crap and the two replies before I make any judgements concerning whether the facts have been finally determined by either of them...

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • Rich,
    I won't comment on the ETH'ers promoting "EM theories" as they fail as "science"

    Taking all of the reports as "factual" All of the EM "weirdness" reported by witnesses ETH'ers assume that the "force" acting on lights, motors, alternators, etc is stopping these things by external EM force. That is not possible without killing the device [car / flashlight/ etc.].

    Electrons travel along a wire in parallel with the wire. They emit a field which is perpendicular to the wire. To kill the flow of electrons [that is, stop the device from operating] you either have to break the wire or block" that perpendicular field. All of the reported EM events end when the device becomes operational once again. [This assumes that what ever is causing the phenomena isn't directly manipulating the observer]

    Humanity does not have a non-destructive means to use an EM field to stop and restaart the functionality of an EM device..[microwaves can kill electronics but can't do the non-destructive "magic" reported].

    My father, as you know, thought that none of the people that throw "EM" or "Electro-magnetics" around as the "Phlebotinum" solution for "ETH" propulsion or car stoppage were worth much. His ultimate conclusion was either "something" was using a force akin to Caravanca's Distortion Theory or Vallee's ideas of "The Other" OR whatever was causing the alleged "EM" phenomena was able to supersede / manipulate two fundamental constants see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permeability_(electromagnetism) and "permitivity [e0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_permittivity [µ0]". Humanity is unable to change "fundamental constants". Oliver_Heaviside#Electromagnetic_terms


    As for wacky ideas--a recent "in the news" academic paper about "Pseudo-profound Bullsh*t" http://journal.sjdm.org/15/15923a/jdm15923a.pdf by several academics tried [and failed!] to actually make a scientific case against said "PPB affliction" of the ignorant. In fact blog.devicerandom points out the authors are wearing the Emperor's new clothes as their "proof" fails to be rigorous enough to pass scientific muster and itself is "PPB".

    regards!

    By Blogger Joel Crook, at Monday, August 20, 2018  

  • Joel, are you lumping Persinger in with 'ETH'ers promoting "EM theories" as they fail as "science"' or pursuing another tenuously related line of thought?

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Tuesday, August 21, 2018  

  • It's difficult to learn anything if you already know everything.

    By Blogger esp.philbrook, at Thursday, August 30, 2018  

Post a Comment

<< Home