UFO Conjectures

Sunday, September 29, 2019

UFOs do not exist? Apparently the world doesn’t exist either….

Copyright 2019, InterAmerica, Inc.

Zoam Chomsky’s rabid mantra that UFOs do not exist gets support, of a kind, from philosophy professor (University of Bonn) Markus Gabriel in his book (pictured).

The new book that I got this week (as noted here) is a plea for the new realistic ontology being touted by some rogue philosophers, the point of which is that postmodernism is dead (along with metaphysics and constructivism) and new realism takes their place or hoping to take their place among philosophers of the day.

Immanuel Kant, to whom constructivism is attributed, is lambasted by Professor Gabriel (and many contemporary philosophers also).

I’m no Kant fan; his convoluted philosophical prose offputting for me since my college days, and discounted by sensible intellectuals and academics all over the place.

But Kantian exposition is no worse, and considerably better than the ramblings of those advocating “new realism” including a guy I actually like: Slavoj Žižek


I replied here, to a comment from Bryan Sentes, how much I disregard and dislike modern philosophy – all philosophy from the Enlightenment period on pretty much – considering it a hodgepodge of linguistic mangling and intellectual madness.

Jacques Derrida, a favorite of mine, held this:

"Arche-writing" (French: archi-écriture) is a term used by French philosopher Jacques Derrida in his attempt to re-orient the relationship between speech and writing. Derrida argued that as far back as Plato, speech had been always given priority over writing. [From the Internet]

“Plato … in his Phaedrus complained that dependence on written texts undermines our habits of memory.” [NYRB, June 27, 2019, Page 55]

“Heraclitus: ‘Listening not to me but to the logos, it is wise to agree that all things are one.” [ibid, Page 57] This to the dismay of a reader here who thinks “all things are not one” – a modern view.

My point is that modern philosophy has lost its way and is engaged in conscious intellectual madness, thus providing no help in resolving reality and certainly nothing relevant to the UFO mystery, as Zoam’s articulated ramblings confirm.

But the “new realism” is with us and adding to the existential [in the current misuse of that term] problems we are all faced with.

Again, I concede that common sense is as good as academic rumination, and resorting to philosophy is not helpful, although one can find viable truths in the Pre-Socratics and Platonic/Aristotelian schools which modern philosophers have corrupted by distorting or “updating” that early Greek thought.

Gabriel’s suggestion that the world does not exist although the things in it do exist is a prime example of how insane thinking has become popular among academics and ersatz scholars.

N.B. I love Zoam Chomsky; it's just his "UFOs do not exist and have never existed" dogma that's at issue.

RR

26 Comments:

  • If the world does not exist then neither does a book telling us that "the world does not exist." When I took philosophy I believe we called this a contradiction in terms.

    By Blogger Dominick, at Monday, September 30, 2019  

  • Well I won't knock Zoam but UFO's do exist sorry Zoam....What I mean by exist is that there are things that float around our skies that we cannot identify...What it don't is that these things are little green men from the planet Nibiru or some shit their not...Nibiru don't exist and there is no evidence aliens exist.

    By Blogger Phil, at Monday, September 30, 2019  

  • Right, Phil. "There are stories of such things, but never the things themselves."

    Yes, people fail to identify things they see in the sky and tell stories about these events, but never have those various stimuli been shown to be anything other than ordinary objects of well known identities. So there are no real "UFOs" of any kind.

    The very idea "UFO" is absurd. As I once told Dom: Imagine you could see unambiguous and persistent unidentifiable things in the sky. That's not the world we live in.

    All we have are no more than ghost stories that compose the "UFO" myth, a delusion.

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Tuesday, October 01, 2019  

  • >> it's just his "UFOs do not exist and have never existed" dogma that's at issue.<<

    It's not as if I'm the only hardcore advocate of the Null and PSH for "UFO" reports.

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Tuesday, October 01, 2019  

  • I kmow Zoam but I don't give a damn about other "skeptics" - they aren't brilliant like you.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, October 01, 2019  

  • Well, what we have to do is get those who do believe to come to a consensus and stop assuming that just because something is "unidentified" it's aliens from another planet.

    By Blogger Phil, at Tuesday, October 01, 2019  

  • @Zoam 'never have those various stimuli been shown to be anything other than ordinary objects of well known identities'

    Here we go again - a sweeping, categorical statement that is simply (and self-evidently) NOT TRUE.

    The 'well-known identities' of the Nimitz/Roosevelt objects are what, exactly?

    Do enlighten us all - oh and while you're at it, be a good citizen and let the Navy & Pentagon (as well as Congress, The War Zone & Politico) in on your selfless, single-handed research into this matter and its revelatory findings.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Thursday, October 03, 2019  

  • @Phil - How does one 'come to a consensus' as to what something is when - as you rightly note - it remains UNIDENTIFIED (hence the name of the recent show concerning the Nimitz/Roosevelt encounters)

    No one with any sense 'assumes' these things are 'aliens from another planet' but as they remain unidentified, and their origins unknown, all possibilities remain open until categorically disproved.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Thursday, October 03, 2019  

  • @Zoam - 'The very idea "UFO" is absurd. As I once told Dom: Imagine you could see unambiguous and persistent unidentifiable things in the sky. That's not the world we live in.'

    The ambiguous quantum world of particle/wave dualities, uncertainties and probabilities (which even Einstein found 'absurd' and refused to accept) is not the 'world we live in' yet it is this unseen and imperceptible world which underlies and informs the apparently solid and predictable Newtonian mechanics of our own 'macro' reality - NOT the other way around.

    Our ordinary, everyday perceptions of what does or does not constitute 'reality' are at best, incomplete and in many instances demonstrable (though often convenient and practicable) illusions. 'And the Sunrise and sunset times for today are...'

    Admittedly, the question as to what UFOs are is not something that impinges on or affects the average person's everyday existence, nor is the Uncertainty Principle, the wave/particle duality or CERN's confirmation of the Higgs-Boson particle.

    Unfortunately (as Einstein eventually learned to his cost) simply refusing to acknowledge or engage with (repeatedly observed and documented) aspects of reality you personally find 'absurd' and/or of no apparent consequence to your day to day existence does not then render such things 'non-existent'.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Thursday, October 03, 2019  

  • @zoamchomsky

    Very good points. I guess some part of me wants the UFOs to be something paranormal or weird, but it´s more probable they´re something more mundane. But I´m still wondering what it is that triggers the UFO experience (with close encounters and aliens) or is it the same mechanism that triggers the ghost sightings and monsters?

    Our brains (and our feeble senses) are just inadequate to perceive reality.

    By Blogger Jerry Cornelius, at Thursday, October 03, 2019  

  • "Dee" apparently still believes in ETHer Tom DeLonge's stupid media hype.

    For the hundredth time, the US Navy has already said it's just a lot of nonsense.

    "To the disappointment of believers, most reported phenomena are probably due to something a bit more mundane than extraterrestrials taking a joy ride through our atmosphere. In addition to spotting experimental aircraft being tested, aviators may simply be succumbing to optical illusions or experiencing radar glitches."

    USOs Not UFOs Have Been the Greatest Threat to the Navy

    Navy Pilot’s 2004 UFO: A Comedy of Errors

    The Pentagon’s UFOs
    How a Multimedia Entertainment Company created a UFO news story



    https://www.navalhistory.org/2019/06/03/usos-not-ufos-have-been-the-greatest-threat-to-the-navy

    https://skepticalinquirer.org/2018/05/navy_pilots_2004_ufo_a_comedy_of_errors/

    https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/pentagon-ufos-to-the-stars-academy-ttsa-ufo-media-frenzy/

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Thursday, October 03, 2019  

  • "Dee" says

    >> Unfortunately (as Einstein eventually learned to his cost) simply refusing to acknowledge or engage with (repeatedly observed and documented) aspects of reality you personally find 'absurd' and/or of no apparent consequence to your day to day existence does not then render such things 'non-existent'.<<

    Oh. Dee, you are so deliciously naive. But still, I like your writing!

    We could substitute the Tooth Fairy, Easter Bunny, or my favorite "Unicorns From Outer Space" (UFOs) in your false comparison of QM to "UFOs."

    That's one thing.

    The other thing is that, as Terry--who is quite the natural logician--will agree, you don't explain one so-called mystery with another.

    That's All!

    Good attempt, but you could learn a lot about "what not to do" from this one old friend of mine. It's an alternative to Sagan's "Skeptic's Baloney Detection Kit":

    https://quasar.as.utexas.edu/BillInfo/Quack.html

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Friday, October 04, 2019  

  • @"Zoam" - 'USOs Not UFOs Have Been the Greatest Threat to the Navy' - well indeed!

    The Nimitz & Roosevelt objects were observed both over the water and below the surface as well as emerging from/descending into the ocean as, historically, have many other unknown objects over the years, particularly in the Pacific South-west.

    They are thus 'USOs' themselves and as I've repeatedly stated (although not on a hundred separate occasions - 'I've told you a MILLION times, STOP EXAGGERATING!') these things have been seen to originate from and return to our oceans, NOT interstellar space. (It's regularly noted of course that, paradoxically, we know much less about the depths of our own planet's oceans than the galaxy and wider cosmos.)

    I'm NOT (nor ever have been) an ETH advocate or believer (as I've clearly and repeatedly stated) so don't keep throwing that old chestnut at me in the vain hope it'll stick.

    Similarly, I don't 'believe' Tom DeLonge's 'stupid media hype' as you put it.

    I've neither read nor am personally aware of any statements by DeLonge concerning his own beliefs and/or experiences (I'm not on Facebook, Instagram and what have you, I don't 'follow him on Twitter' and have never searched online to find out 'what he's up to' - I'm not interested.) I've only come across mentions of him in articles/interviews with individuals involved in the Nimitz/Roosevelt incidents and seen him in the context of 'Unidentified' where he largely took a backseat and didn't say much at all.

    If the increase in coverage and renewed attention of serious journalists to the subject is down solely to his involvement - then good luck to him and long may it continue!

    What I do 'believe' in is the credibility and sincerity of the witnesses and testimonies from those present (F-18 pilots, radar operatives and other crew members) at the time of these incidents who had direct experience of or interaction with the objects in 'real-time' in terms of tracking them as radar targets or were actual eye-witnesses to the objects at close quarters.

    The last two links you've supplied are from 'skeptic' sites which have an agenda and never actually demonstrate any of the open-minded, neutral and objective 'scepticism' they supposedly advocate, regarding everything through a pre-existing 'confirmation bias' prism of there's 'nothing to it' (much like yourself).

    In support of this rigid stance, convenient 'facts' are strategically 'cherry-picked' whilst the often numerous 'inconvenient truths' at odds with this viewpoint are routinely dismissed or ignored. (Again, much like yourself.)

    By Blogger DrDee, at Friday, October 04, 2019  

  • The objects (as of two weeks ago) remain under official Navy investigation and have neither been identified nor dismissed as 'mundane objects' contrary to demonstrably FALSE 'skeptical' assertions to the contrary and despite the earliest of these incidents having occurred way back in 2004.

    Here are just two examples of the CURRENT, official Navy position (conveniently omitted by the 'skeptic' sites in order to bolster their own one-sided take on things) covered by credible, unbiased outlets with no 'skeptic' agenda which as usual, set out to discredit and character assassinate the key witnesses rather than address the officially endorsed facts as stated. Hey - why not try playing the ball sometime and not the man?

    From LiveScience.com (17 days ago):
    'Joseph Gradisher, a spokesperson for the Deputy Chief of Naval Operations for Information Warfare, announced that the Navy officially considers the craft in these three videos "unidentified aerial phenomena." That means that the eerie videos are authentic — and that the objects, which were detected in restricted military training airspaces in 2004 and 2015, were not supposed to be there. The objects still have not been successfully identified as any known type of aircraft.

    The UFO footage was also never cleared for public release, Gradisher told The Black Vault — meaning these are three unidentified phenomena you were never supposed to know about.'

    And from Time.com Sept 18th 2019:

    'According to Gradisher, investigations into unidentified objects are driven by the danger they pose to pilots.

    “Incursions by [unidentified aerial phenomena] represent a safety hazard to aviators and security issues for operations,” he tells TIME. “The Navy is investigating the incursions seen in the three videos,” adding that sightings “occur frequently.”

    Gradisher explained to the Black Vault the Navy prefers the term unidentified aerial phenomena over “UFO.”

    Much as you dismiss as 'unworthy of consideration' (due to what you perceive as 'subjective bias') all reports by witnesses with a stated belief (often only subsequent to their own life-changing UFO encounter) that there is indeed something to the UFO phenomenon, we can validly apply the same criteria to the opposing belief system and its 'cast-iron skeptic' adherents dismissing their biased, subjective and selective statements in similar fashion.

    The 'skeptics' remind me of the Scientologists - an agenda-driven belief system which when all else fails resorts to systematic (and invariably false) insults, accusations and personal attacks on their unfortunate victims who don't share these beliefs. It's low, cheap and unworthy behaviour and demonstrates they can't win an argument fairly by recourse to the established facts.

    It's the same attitude spectacularly and catastrophically displayed by arch-skeptic Edward Condon in his arrogant and wilful destruction of the Project Blue Book data (thus preventing any further scientific analysis or study) since he'd unilaterally 'come to the conclusion' (how exactly 18 months before the data had been analysed?) that there was 'nothing to it'.

    Again, when confronted by the supposedly 'rational' yet seemingly desperate actions and statements of such clearly biased and agenda-driven 'skeptics', who seem hell-bent on preserving and reinforcing their own viewpoint at all costs, rather than establishing what the TRUTH is, I'm compelled once more to repeat the words of the late, great Bill Hicks:

    'Wow - how fucking scientific!'

    By Blogger DrDee, at Friday, October 04, 2019  

  • @'Zoam' (A.S. you prefer to be called)

    Well, we're all 'naive' compared to you aren't we, oh omniscient one?

    I'm not equating quantum mechanics with UFOs, I'm merely using the analogy that quantum processes are neither perceptible nor have any ordinarily discernible effect on most people's everyday 'reality'. This doesn't then mean it isn't part of (or indeed completely informs and determines) that reality or 'doesn't exist'.

    You (and others) appear to be basically asserting (like Dr. Johnson) that 'reality' is merely that which you can see, hear, touch etc. and everything else is nonsense when we all know there's much, much more to it than that aa well as (potentially) a 'new physics' which we've (possibly) only just begun to make the first tentative steps towards.

    All a prescriptive list of supposed 'quack terms' (that must not be mentioned) does is close down and stifle debate and discussion, much like 'politically correct' lists of proscribed terms do.

    UFOs may well be an aspect of physics or 'reality' that does indeed lie outside the current scientific 'paradigm' (uh-oh proscribed 'nutjob' word!)

    If we can't raise or debate these concepts without being immediately deemed a 'nutjob', (as any attempt to rationally discuss issues surrounding immigration used to automatically & inevitably prompt the playing of the 'racism' card, thus silencing it from the get-go) let alone investigate and study anomalous phenomena without being tarred with the same brush (as the stigma surrounding the study of UFOs has long prevented the involvement of 'serious' scientists and researchers) then we aren't going to get anywhere.

    EVERYTHING should be up for debate and discussion and a checklist of proscribed terms/concepts that cannot be mentioned for fear of ridicule and condemnation sounds worryingly akin to some irrational, Orwellian totalitarian dystopia than any open, rational society.

    It also explains a lot about your rigid viewpoint. Not that it's in any way 'yours' - it's a learnt, prescriptive set of 'rules' for scientific cultural conformity.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Friday, October 04, 2019  

  • "Dee;" Why do you even bother? Is it that you don't know or can't understand why?

    We've heard this very same baloney argument from the first weeks of your postings. As I said then, it's exactly what we've heard from a certain sort of certifiable "UFO" lunatic for decades. It all amounts to about a dozen well known fallacious appeals, including "blame the skeptics," deny the skeptics' facts and reason since we're all so "close minded," appeal to the philosophy of science (of which you know little or nothing), and so on. Just look up the page; they're glaringly obvious to the rational reader. It's the stupid and boring old Woo-Woo Credo all over again.

    And this is all because you have false beliefs about the world. "Dee," if there were real "UFOs" of any kind, we'd all know it already. It wouldn't be the subject of a fossilized pseudoscience. Can you grasp that simple fact or are you totally mental?

    It's not my fault or any other skeptics responsibility for your false and frankly stupid and silly beliefs about the world. Your "UFO" diseased mind is just some sort of hysterical intelligence. There's no real veracious evidence of such things but you'll desperately grasp at anything, no matter how pathetic, to justify your obviously false belief. Even DeLonge's carnival show of long debunked flying-saucer claims. Don't kid yourself, old-time Believer Bigelow's AATIP and new-ager Delongs's TTSA are all one and the same money-grabbing SCAM. That's who you're in bed with.

    Grow Up, Kiddo!

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Sunday, October 06, 2019  

  • Thanks, Jerry!

    You're right. I agree. I'd categorize most "UFO" reports as individual or small group scares. It all depends on the culture and predisposition of the witness:

    An ambiguous stimulus is perceived as a threat. And the individual or group leader quickly defines that threat as a "UFO," a ghost or monster depending on the type of stimuli and the environmental circumstances, usually dark and/or enclosed spaces.

    In most cases, it's a simple matter of misperception and culturally supplied images or tropes, identities, that give a context to the ambiguous threatening "other" which other times could be nothing more than a familiar star or planet.

    From there the individual or group settle on that identity and the situation is soon resolved and they begin the task of narrative creation. And so a "UFO" or ghost story is born.

    Best!

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Sunday, October 06, 2019  

  • Zoam I think they call it "argument from ignorance" they go from not knowing what the hell it is to it being aliens from another planet!

    By Blogger Phil, at Sunday, October 06, 2019  

  • @Zoam & @Phil Ah, yes my 'argument from ignorance' - whereas you two of course (as we're all constantly reminded) know everything!

    You're both obsessed with 'space aliens', 'ghosts' and 'monsters'. I've never mentioned anything of the sort but you still insist on using this as some sort of brick-bat.

    I'll reiterate it ONCE more (as above) and then you can both go back to making up your silly bloody stories and fictional allegations again (whatever turns you on)

    The NAVY (as of two-weeks ago) is STILL investigating the Nimitz & Roosevelt sightings as UNEXPLAINED aerial objects.

    This is in response (as quoted above) to concerns about pilot safety and consequently, procedures by which pilots and other personnel can report unexplained sightings have been simplified and updated.

    No one (other than you two) have mentioned, nor suggested, these unidentified objects are 'alien spacecraft'.

    The objects themselves, however, are regarded as a real, potential threat to Navy aircraft and deemed significant enough to warrant a full and ongoing investigation as to what they are.

    THAT'S IT - END OF.

    Anything else is speculation and conjecture - which is fine of course - but don't try and portray it as FACT when it clearly and demonstrably isn't anything of the sort.

    You two can carry on bullshitting and pretending all you want that 'they're not real', 'they've been explained' (what are the NAVY investigating then ffs?) and I apparently keep saying 'it's aliens' etc, etc.

    Why not try sticking to the FACTS for a change, eh? As opposed to your fantasy 'skeptic' agenda, made-up accusations (or LIES as one might uncharitably call them) and the usual tedious character assassination.

    Laughable.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Monday, October 07, 2019  

  • "You're both obsessed with 'space aliens', 'ghosts' and 'monsters'. I've never mentioned anything of the sort but you still insist on using this as some sort of brick-bat."

    It's not our problem you have trouble with reality is it? Furthermore I don't think aliens exist, never seen a ghost and monsters are pseudoscience BS...Secondly I never said UFOs were not real...And where have I said anything was fact? When it comes to UFOs there are no facts only witness accounts that can hardly be trusted.

    UFO believers are jumping all over this Nimitz incident as if it's some kind of huge break through it's not...The UFO community has nothing to prove that these things are aliens from another planet..Stop depending on the military to prove your argument from ignorance theories.

    And know it alls! The only one coming off as a know it all here is you...You're attitude is the same as many on the internet when your etched in stone theories are not accepted you resort to name calling and insults...

    Throw away that damn college degree and try using common sense for a change.

    By Blogger Phil, at Tuesday, October 08, 2019  

  • @Phil All complete horseshit as usual and literally nothing to do with what I've actually said.

    Haven't proffered any 'theories' or called you names I've just restated what the Navy says and called out the bullshit accusations, none of which I've said.

    And 'common sense' is just a lame alibi used to close down and marginalise all thought and opinion that challenges the dominant discourse, without which nothing changes or progresses.

    Fucking tedious as ever.

    By Blogger DrDee, at Tuesday, October 08, 2019  

  • DrDee:

    You are the highlight here at this blog.

    If you want or need anything, contact me privately at rrrgroup@gmail.com

    Luv ya, buddy boy.

    RR



    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, October 08, 2019  

  • Yeah he's a damn highlight alright question is what kind...Oh I know! An educated hypocrite! I bet he's friends with Nancy Lieder as well. At least I know where all the dumb asses for UFOs congregate. Here!

    By Blogger Phil, at Tuesday, October 08, 2019  

  • @Rich - Hahahaha - Zoam'll be apoplectic!

    He's 'The Way, the Truth & the Light' surely! :D

    I don't need nowt Rich, ta very much - but jolly decent of you to ask tho' (that said, if you've a few hundred thousand quid going spare all donations will of course be gratefully received - hahahahahahaha!) ;)

    By Blogger DrDee, at Tuesday, October 08, 2019  

  • "Dee;" You're Delusional.

    That is, you think your imaginings are facts in the world, but they're not.

    Show us exactly where the US Navy or the Pentagon said that "UFOs" are REAL.

    I bet you can't. I know you can't because neither has said such stupid stuff.

    They said the stolen videos were real--stolen Navy property--that doesn't say anything about what's on the videos.

    Just how much stupider can you get? And you gleefully parade your idiocy.

    Geesh! What a Moron!

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Sunday, October 13, 2019  

  • You've got it, Phil!

    "Dee's" probably friends with Jim Penniston as well, and like Jim is receiving binary coded messages from space aliens.

    That's why he wears that aluminum-foil hat!

    Hahaha!

    By Blogger zoamchomsky, at Sunday, October 13, 2019  

Post a Comment

<< Home