Dude: it's precisely the New Scientist article you posted earlier that calls this (and its fellow cheerleaders popping up in countless newsfeeds) into question. (And let's not get into that it's IBM questioning its competitor, nor the very nature of such tests or proofs of concept...).
What did I misread? That Google's claim is questionable?
I quote from the article you share:
'IBM ... *questioned* Google's prematurely released results in a blog post Monday.' [my emphasis] This is the topic of the earlier article I shared of FB you shared here.
Moreover, if you read the article carefully, undermining the hype are many verbs in the conditional and litotic admissions, such as '"Realizing the full promise of quantum computing ... still requires *technical leaps*," the researchers said in their paper.'
Much more of course could be said concerning those *technical leaps* (and I have, and linked to much better informed commentators doing so).
RE my reservations: "It would be tempting to conclude from all this that the basic problems are solved in principle and the path to a future of ubiquitous quantum computing is now just a matter of engineering. But that would be a mistake. The fundamental physics of quantum computing is far from solved and can’t be readily disentangled from its implementation."
The author of this lengthy, balanced article, cites Gil Kalai as well, who I've cited, and whom I find more compelling than those who have to justify the hundreds of millions of dollars invested to date in their tinkering.
The title (for crying out loud) states IBM calls Google's claim into question: "IBM says Google may not have reached quantum supremacy after all"
First line of the article (the first you shared, that I had shared on FB...): "The new dawn of quantum computing may not be as close as we thought." Last line of the article's opening paragraph: "...new work from researchers at IBM suggests those claims may not hold up."
I continue: "...according to new work from a team at IBM, Google missed something." Further: "Google didn’t actually demonstrate quantum supremacy, and the race is still on." "This just goes to show that claims of quantum supremacy should be taken with a grain of salt..."
The article in question as the quotations above show concerns IBM's criticisms of Google's claim, not Google's "success".
...of course, you're claiming I misread the latest article you shared--sorry about that--days of moving will do that to a man's concentration.
I stand by the few passages I quote from it, above. (I wanted to spare everyone's patience by not quoting too much, at length.) However triumphant its tone, it still quotes those critical of Google's claim and probing of just what in fact has been accomplished.
I maintain, not without reason, "claims of quantum supremacy should be taken with a grain of salt..."
12 Comments:
Dude: it's precisely the New Scientist article you posted earlier that calls this (and its fellow cheerleaders popping up in countless newsfeeds) into question. (And let's not get into that it's IBM questioning its competitor, nor the very nature of such tests or proofs of concept...).
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
I wanted to promote the link again...
Nothing is in question. You misread.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
What did I misread? That Google's claim is questionable?
I quote from the article you share:
'IBM ... *questioned* Google's prematurely released results in a blog post Monday.' [my emphasis] This is the topic of the earlier article I shared of FB you shared here.
Moreover, if you read the article carefully, undermining the hype are many verbs in the conditional and litotic admissions, such as '"Realizing the full promise of quantum computing ... still requires *technical leaps*," the researchers said in their paper.'
Much more of course could be said concerning those *technical leaps* (and I have, and linked to much better informed commentators doing so).
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
RE my reservations: "It would be tempting to conclude from all this that the basic problems are solved in principle and the path to a future of ubiquitous quantum computing is now just a matter of engineering. But that would be a mistake. The fundamental physics of quantum computing is far from solved and can’t be readily disentangled from its implementation."
The author of this lengthy, balanced article, cites Gil Kalai as well, who I've cited, and whom I find more compelling than those who have to justify the hundreds of millions of dollars invested to date in their tinkering.
https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-era-of-quantum-computing-is-here-outlook-cloudy-20180124/
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
"IBM questioned" -- give me a break!
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Give you a break? Do I misunderstand you? You claim I misread: what did I misread?
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Bryan, my boy...
You have got to get over your negativity about quantum computing.
Of course you can dig up naysayers.
But it's futile.
Quantum computing is inevitable.
Accept the possibility and move on.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
You misread the piece.
It tells of a success, not a failure.
You're just seeing the negative comments from competitors.
Move on.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Sorry, pal, you can't accuse me of misreading:
The title (for crying out loud) states IBM calls Google's claim into question: "IBM says Google may not have reached quantum supremacy after all"
First line of the article (the first you shared, that I had shared on FB...): "The new dawn of quantum computing may not be as close as we thought." Last line of the article's opening paragraph: "...new work from researchers at IBM suggests those claims may not hold up."
I continue: "...according to new work from a team at IBM, Google missed something." Further: "Google didn’t actually demonstrate quantum supremacy, and the race is still on." "This just goes to show that claims of quantum supremacy should be taken with a grain of salt..."
The article in question as the quotations above show concerns IBM's criticisms of Google's claim, not Google's "success".
Puh-lease.
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Again, IBM.
What's wrong with you? It's IBM after all, which has a major stake in a Google failure or success.
It's not an objective stance.
That you keep flogging it is worrisome.
Move on. Let it rest.
It's small potatoes after all, no matter how it's mashed.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
...of course, you're claiming I misread the latest article you shared--sorry about that--days of moving will do that to a man's concentration.
I stand by the few passages I quote from it, above. (I wanted to spare everyone's patience by not quoting too much, at length.) However triumphant its tone, it still quotes those critical of Google's claim and probing of just what in fact has been accomplished.
I maintain, not without reason, "claims of quantum supremacy should be taken with a grain of salt..."
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Oh my God, your brain is addled from your moving.
Can I send you an alka-seltzer or something?
Quantum computing is here, not for us peons yet, but will show up on our laps in the near (!) future.
Count on it, invest in it, savor it.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, October 23, 2019
Post a Comment
<< Home