UFO Conjectures

Thursday, July 02, 2020

From Jose Caravaca [Portions I find interesting are placed in Bold type, RR]

Copyright 2020,  José Antonio Caravaca

UFOS: An Unknown "Psychic" Virtual Reality? By José Caravaca
That UFO manifestations, especially close encounters, possess not only human characteristics, but manifestly socio-cultural aspects analogous to those developed by our civilization, are very evident.

The interaction with the UFO phenomenon, is produced, based on some very concrete and specific concepts, both aesthetic and narrative that are structured on human knowledge. And all this is shown in a disordered way, since each witness interacts in a very determined and different way with the paradigm, but under the same premises.

An example. The behaviors of the ufonauts have been described in different ways. Basically in the UFO literature we find the following behaviors of the UFO occupants: elusive, fearful, violent, communicative, indifferent...

We can also extrapolate a series of basic activities that ufonauts perform when they land: examining the surroundings, taking samples from the ground or repairing their vehicles. And the curious thing is that all these behaviors and activities are shown and exhibited with human gestures (in the face and body) and even using tools and utensils as those of our technology.

But what I want to emphasize is that all these points are shown in a disorderly way, even chaotic, as if the phenomenon did not have a defined purpose or a clear objective, as if it has no memory. Let me explain.

We can find a UFO encounter where the ufonaut is communicative, and later we find another event where the occupant of the flying saucer flees from the place as if he had never seen an Earthling. Then we find a case of an indifferent or violent humanoid.

Invariably, everything starts again as in an endless roulette that does not stop spinning, and where the behaviors that we are going to find in future incidents seem to be unpredictable. Or are they?

From my point of view the personal and non-transferable interaction of each witness with the phenomenon makes the ufonauts behave in a certain way, possibly in line with internal psychological factors of the observers (fear, curiosity, fascination, shyness, etc). In the same way, the ufonauts show us the interior of their spaceship and invite us on a space tour and in other cases they flee in fear of our mere presence.

Is the witness who visits the interior of a UFO more curious than the witness who claims that the ufonauts fled the site? To what extent can a person's courage, curiosity or fear determine the degree of immersion in these experiences? Are the actions taken by the ufonauts resonant with the abilities of the witnesses in their ordinary lives?

The UFOs, as an important fact to take into account, do not have memory to transfer from one incident to another: neither in aesthetics nor in narrative, beyond the broad outlines, because most of their content is based on a joint and unpredictable construction, that forges at the same moment (so there is no before or after) between the paradigm itself and the witnesses, full of nuances and differences.

UFO events are an enormous psychic architecture that can, at times, interact physically with the environment and the witnesses, causing all kinds of consequences. But if we carefully observe this physical aspect of UFOs, we will see that it also behaves in a random and disorderly way, sometimes the lights of the UFOs burn, and in other incidents they don't, the saucers leave traces in some places and in others they don't. In the case of UFO encounters, sometimes flying saucers have interiors without any accessories (austere in detail), and in other cases they are full of screens, computers, chairs, levers, etc.

And all this is propitiated, perhaps, by the innate capacity of each individual to interact with a greater degree of psychic involvement with the phenomenon.

UFOs come from an unknown dimension, highly immersive and malleable to the presence and interaction of witnesses. And so each witness has the opportunity to translate different narrative and visual schemes into their experience. UFOs represent an artificial "reality" built on human socio-cultural elements, by trying to decode a wide and disconcerting unknown cognitive phenomenon that goes beyond the range of ordinary senses.

The closest thing we know to all this would be an immersion in a powerful virtual reality, with physical effects, which would originate at the very moment of our connection, and whose characters and scenarios react to our unconscious desires, without the individual himself being aware that the whole universe he is witnessing and experiencing is being constructed in part, not only with his presence, but, with high doses of creativity, depending on each witness.

JAC

17 Comments:

  • Greetings,

    “That UFO manifestations, especially close encounters, possess not only human characteristics, but manifestly socio-cultural aspects analogous to those developed by our civilization, are very evident”.

    ===> What did you expect when an individual facing a prosaic event, object, but not identified for what it is in reality? And you ufologists collecting such events and jumping on them?

    Our Brain doesn't like a “whole”, then is figurating/concepting to make sens for what he did not identify, and using our prevalious concepts, background. It is only top-down processing by our brain (or drived by concepts).

    A testimony which will be collected by ufologist ! And you making your romance and fantasy (which will never join a peer reviewed Journal).

    What Caravaca feels as “chaotic” is only the inter-individual differencies. We are all different. Therefore, when a witness doesn't recognize dunno what in the sky or at land (or dunno where), he will use is prevalent backgroung to produce his narrative (cause the UFO myth) aka the same top-down cognitive processings the ufologists like to collect. A jeweller will compare the object to a diamond, a peasant the object for like a watering trough, and so on.

    There is no need of “Ufonauts”, or“external agents”.

    The distorsion theory have none sens in Human Science. Only Ufologists like Jacques Vallée would congratulate it :p

    In few words, José Carava Theory will never reach a serious peer-reviewed journal, and it's part of its modern myth.

    Well, that's ufology, after all ;)

    Gilles Fernandez

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Sunday, July 05, 2020  

  • Gilles I don't know how many times you've commented that my work wasn't published in a serious peer-reviewed journal. What I am clear about is that you are discussing an issue that you do not know in depth. Tell me just one psychosocial phenomenon comparable to UFOs that has led to many people becoming "infected" (hallucinating as those who have never investigated a UFO case say) and seeing something that only exists in their head... just one...

    By the way, have you ever humbly asked yourself where you've gotten to???

    Saludos

    By Blogger jacaravaca, at Sunday, July 05, 2020  

  • RR,

    I'm in agreement in/with the interesting sections you highlighted.

    Hello Giles,

    Is there a peer review for UFO theory?

    I find, and like, that Jose starts his description of his theory considerations with "especially close encounters" - I have to like that as of all sightings reported, and notably that we consider, those of the close encounters always seem the hardest to believe and thus a psychological event seem the likely but beyond that we go reaching out.

    Those who have not had a UAP/UFO sighting experience are at a critical disadvantage, they have not seen one. Those who have had the experience (clean, sober, and etc.) rightfully must consider the alternative explanations in their observation.

    Hello Jose,

    Your theory is well thought out but a tough one without some background on your projection into "UFOs come from an unknown dimension, highly immersive and malleable to the presence and interaction of witnesses." I'd sure like more on that.

    BD

    By Blogger Bryan Daum, at Sunday, July 05, 2020  

  • Greetings,

    There exist several university theses or works (mainly in Human Sciences). Paolo Toselli catalogue lists them (for an not actualized version- I'm not at home, see http://www.euroufo.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/UfoTheses2010.xls ).

    Among them, many SPH “defenders” have accepted the “peer-review” processing (when you submit or pretend for a thesis (PhD), well you are facing a Jury. For example, the one of my friend, Jean-Michel Abrassart, https://dial.uclouvain.be/pr/boreal/object/boreal:177063?fbclid=IwAR232Y-8SgYuY00RRafCbYdr9A7U__zjJa5qQ00_hf2KH6otTBtH6EvbxCk

    There exist several papers in famous peer-reviewed journals too (again mainly in Human Sciences) and defending the SPH.

    “Ufologists” or “exotic hypotheses defenders” need to create their own “journal” to play the peer-reviewed game (like the JSE) ...https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society_for_Scientific_Exploration

    Regards,

    Gilles

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Monday, July 06, 2020  

  • Guilles... I am asking this question again because, evidently, your negationist enthusiasm prevents you from reading correctly at the first glance, so tell me one single psychosocial phenomenon of hallucinatory "contagion" such as that shown by the UFO phenomenon. One.

    saludos

    By Blogger jacaravaca, at Monday, July 06, 2020  

  • Hello José,

    “Negationist enthousiam” : Thank you for your “Godwin point” :(

    I cant answer to your question, because it is a sophism at this stage. You enter as (false) premises that the UFO phenomenom is a psychological phenomenon of hallucinatory "contagion". And from this premisse, you ask a question.
    But where is the scientific evidence of this? It is only a "claim".
    The only hallucinatory contagion I know (I mean scientificaly documented) is the very rare in “folie à deux”, then one individual to another(s) (and it is a form of psychiatric psychosis – the individuals must be psychotic) (ie: Dantendorfer K, Maierhofer D, Musalek M (1997). "Induced hallucinatory psychosis (folie à deux hallucinatoire): pathogenesis and nosological position". Psychopathology. 30 (6): 309–15.
    It is included in the DSM catalogue (DSM-IV-TR, 297.3.)


    In essence, I cant reply to a question which in the best of my psychological scientific background contains a false premisse. Or, provide me FIRST a scientific article or study validating its premisse. Understand that you claim a premisse in a (pseudo) question to your interlocutor in order to be remain in a circulatory loop / reasoning...

    Despite this, there exist several mass delusions / hysteria / contagions, etc. inside a little groups or large groups, aka a condition in which a large or little group of people exhibit similar physical or emotional symptoms or mental agitation. For example, it happens in factory, schools, terrorism and (believed) biological attacks/warfare. Kelly–Hopkinsville encounter have been explained by this by some.


    Regards / Saludos,

    Gilles Fernandez

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  

  • (Suite) Looks like a part of my reply was removed cause a bad copy-past in my notepad. Pardon then for its second message, no desire to spam here.

    So, concerning your question (I found a sophism for the reason I gave), I gived you a sort of reply.

    “ so tell me one single psychosocial phenomenon of hallucinatory "contagion" […] One.”

    There is documented evidences in psychiatry that “folie à deux” for psychotic subjects have demonstrated individuals with hallucinatory contagion (and phenomenon not involving UFO in the narratives / symptoms / delirium). I quoted with source (peer-reviewed journal) to show “only one” case which then contradicts your assertion (even if I found your claim only a claim). You then must admit I succeed in your “challenge”.

    Au plaisir d'échanger...

    Regards,

    Gilles

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  


  • Hola Gilles... Their ignorance about the UFO phenomenon astonishes me, the various official commissions of inquiry, raised by governments around the world, is not evidence of a "collective psychosis"? honestly you don't want to see, or understand, your hate controls your reasoning...


    abrazos

    By Blogger jacaravaca, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  

  • Well, José...

    You asked / Challenged me to provide ONE example of hallucinatory "contagion" because for you it would only exist for the "UFO phenomenon" (despite I dont think the ufo phenomenon is an hallucinatory "contagion", but I can forgot it 2 seconds .

    I gave you "one" as you asked/challenged. Period and "Chess and Mat".

    You used a nominal syntagm (hallucinatory contagion) and now jumping to another "collective psychosis" in order to fall back on your feet from the fragile branch of tree on which you sat... Typicall in pseudo or para sciences;)

    Have a nice day, my friend, enjoy "likes" in your FB page, ignore critics, and your days will be fine, thing I which to my old friend you are ;)

    Amitiés,

    Gilles

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  

  • Gilles... As far as I know, we are talking about the same thing, the UFOs, from your point of view, from the position of the psychosocial hypothesis can be interpreted as a hallucinatory contagion and "collective psychosis", unless you define otherwise a hallucinatory phenomenon, which affects many people and seems to be infected by the news, press, comments, etc.
    The problem as I see it, with all due respect to your intellect, is that you raise all sorts of barriers and grammatical subterfuges to avoid substantive debate You insist on the finger... while forgetting that the finger points to the Moon... may you have another good day in your seamless world...


    saludos

    By Blogger jacaravaca, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  

  • Gilles:

    I'd be a little cautious in dismissing "hallucinatory contagion" or "collective psychosis" as a possibility for [some] UFO sightings and/or encounters.

    You've read Jung's book and have come across other writers offering the possibility that such psychological missteps may be endemic to some UFO experiences.

    Your cognitive approach allows for such etiologies, yes?

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Tuesday, July 07, 2020  

  • In his Flying Saucer book, Jung refers to The Angel of Mons (a journalistic / propagandistic hoax) and Fatima; I, too, would be curious how Gilles accounts for the mass "hallucination" reported there and then...

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, July 08, 2020  

  • Hello Bryan,

    Start to considerate and learn, how in (serious) Psychology we receive Carl Jung, and his book about "saucers".

    Second: We & others (skeptics) explained Fatima.

    Therefore, Jung or/and Fatima ?

    Only believers can appeal in 2020 to his book or to Fatima.

    Well, that's ufology, agter all.

    Gilles Fernandez

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Monday, July 13, 2020  

  • "your seamless world..."

    Hello José,

    It is you who are in "seamless world". Soory to wake up.

    Your theory is only constructed from narratives (and then so bad, so poor, zero) than you will have only FB "likes".

    From the narratives, you are elaborating a stupid "theory" which will never reach a peer reviewed journal (excepted to study such modern myth).

    Please wake me up when you have photograph, video or hardwares for your theory! Your romantic view or study, will remain... A cute Romance!

    Gilles Fernandez

    By Blogger Gilles Fernandez, at Monday, July 13, 2020  

  • Well, Gilles, that's not a very substantial (and were I not so charitable, a very respectful) answer.

    I don't invoke Jung as an authority. Clearly you are unfamiliar with my public remarks on Jung and his views on Flying Saucers.

    You explain the mass vision of Fatima? Please link it, if you'd be so kind.

    If you think I'm a believer, please consult Skunkworksblog, or, don't assume you know who you are talking to.

    As we say in Quebec, Tabarnak sangue du Chris'!

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, July 13, 2020  

  • (and for some reason I always insist on mispelling 'sang' as 'sangue'--takes the bite out of even the mock affront from the expression as expressed, tabarnack hosti...)

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Monday, July 13, 2020  

  • Gilles you should control yourself a little, anyone who did not know that you are a brilliant and respected intellectual worldwide, with thousands of readers, would think that you have some envy for the impact of my humbles approaches, because even if it is on Facebook, and other media lower than Science and Nature, the worst thing is to go unnoticed and not be read by anyone...

    saludotes

    By Blogger jacaravaca, at Tuesday, July 14, 2020  

Post a Comment

<< Home