What UFO case has actually provided an ET supposition?
Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.
I, like you, am rather familiar with a large number of UFO
reports, and I have never read one that contains anything that definitively
tells me the thing seen was a space craft from outer space, not one.
Yes, aerial maneuvers often indicate intelligent
manipulation. And reconnoitering waterways and military installations seem to
show observational tendencies or a need for H2O or some element in it.
But does any of that really suggest alien (extraterrestrial)
visitation?
Impressions in the ground, weird noises or smells do not connote outer space visitation either.
Impressions in the ground, weird noises or smells do not connote outer space visitation either.
And the humanoid interactions or perceptions of
humanoid-like entities, which are very likely psychical, in line with what I’m
about to propose, do not infer that the visualized beings are
extraterrestrials, nothing.
Taking Roswell out of the mix, and accepting the Socorro
sighting as an extraordinary mundane event, along with Ken Arnold’s visual
escapade, plus any other sighting you can cite, we are hard-pressed to see any connection
to otherworldly visitors in UFO sightings.
Because UFO sightings are unusual in essence and uncommon by
any evaluation, that doesn’t make them space craft containing outer space visitors.
UFO witnesses project their science-fiction conditioning on their
odd observations.
Early UFO sightings didn’t provoke the idea of creatures from
the cosmos; even the Ancient Astronaut theorists have to admit that. Their
ballyhooed UFO sightings were the vehicles of the gods, for those initially
reporting them.
It’s the imposed science fiction renderings of books, movies
television and later on, with the Frank Scully book and the 1978 Roswell
resurgence, UFOs became encrusted with alien visitation, although nothing
occurred that imposed that idea on the mysterious phenomenon, nothing except
the subliminal idea that such odd things in the sky could only be the product
of advanced species from somewhere else, besides Earth.
There is, as far as I have been able to see, not one iota or
scintilla of detail by any UFO witness, from their reports, that can
knowledgeably insinuate an alien (extraterrestrial) presence.
ETs are a non-intellectually presumed assumption, created
from a conditioned mind-set that is flush with circumstantial fictional
imagination.
I can see how skeptics arrive at their UFO atheism, but not
to see UFOs as something strange from, possibly, a reality other than outer
space is just as fervently asinine.
That’s where I’m continuing to go with this…
RR


12 Comments:
There are at least two motivations for the ETH. One, as you remark, is the cultural conditioning of the witnesses. Another, linked to the first, is official confirmation, c.f. the famous Estimate of the Situation produced under Project Sign (I think: I'm away from my library at the moment). It is also a not untenable argument that the powers-that-be have nurtured the ETH for their own purposes.
Given that there is no perception without cultural determination, the rise of the ETH is understandable and hardly asinine from this point of view, though it surely is as "theory" that ironically flies in the face of the details of the reports (as Vallee has made clear).
By
Bryan Sentes, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
Yes, Bryan, there are ample catalysts for thinking UFOs are ET craft.
I even like the idea, but it flies in the face of an objective look at where we are in he galactic scheme of things.....then there is the Universe itself, a place where our presence is so inconsequential that I'm almost ashamed to be here.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
Hm. I must admit a degree of mystification about what is going on in this post. Answers to the question the title poses seem ready-at-hand.
That being said, I am tempted to address Rich's Inconsequentiality Thesis (RIF): one might ask, given the undeniable scale of the universe (assuming there is no multiverse!) and assuming the given universe is not immortal (it will end, either in heat death or a Big Crunch), what phenomenon would imaginably be significant? Even a transgalactic immortal AI civilization wouldn't rank, it seems to me. And let's imagine said civilization is cunning enough to survive a Big Crunch and continue into the next iteration of a cosmos, even then. So, if nothing can be said to be significant, then nothing can be said to be insignificant either, which entails a reconsideration of just what scale is used to gauge significance....
By
Bryan Sentes, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
Oh my gosh, Bryan...
You stand outside, looking at the night sky and still think we (you and I) are significant?
You feel that you in Canada and me, here, in the States have any relevance to anything, except our personal reality?
What is the significance of Beethoven or Shakespeare in the context of the cosmos?
Come on buddy....your view is bordering on a kind of human hubris, tinged by madness.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
"I can see how skeptics arrive at their UFO atheism, but not to see UFOs as something strange from, possibly, a reality other than outer space...."
Even as the "least likely" explanation for "UFO" reports, the ETH is at least a real, however remote, possibility; all the rest is conspiracy theory, "what if," and pure fantasy.
Since 1896, it's still the supreme Psychosocial hypothesis; remote but real-world Advanced aerospace and "least likely" ET hypotheses; or completely worthless pseudoscientific mumbo jumbo.
"'Alternate reality' talk is not a promising new hypothesis. It is total intellectual abdication," said a great skeptic in 1980.
Thirty-eight years later and ufxxlergy has not progressed one bit. And that's pseudoscience!
By
zoamchomsky, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
Ah, Zoam...
You are anti-alternative to the point of mischief.
Without other realities or UFOs, what would we have? Justin Bieber?
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Tuesday, July 10, 2018
Hmmm. Real knowledge.
By
zoamchomsky, at Friday, July 13, 2018
"Impressions in the ground, weird noises or smells do not connote outer space visitation either."
Actually, they can. Perhaps we are meant to understand you to have included, "in and of themselves". Such noises, etc, MAY connote visitation as much as non-visitation, depending on other evidence. And the fact there may exist non-ET explanations (whether more or less likely) does not necessarily negate the existence of the outer space explanation. To say NONE suggests such is simply erroneous.
By
Jum, at Monday, July 16, 2018
@zoam
As the late, great Ron Nasty sung in his seminal, Tea-fuelled psychedelic epic 'No Jellied Eels, Whatever' (or was it 'Give Booze a Chance?', I forget...)
Nothing is REAL.
We inhabit a structured, Symbolic Order that we impose upon the 'Real' and through which we attempt to 'make sense' of it all - but this itself is an impossibility since the Symbolic is a fabricated 'world of words' that creates a separate, alienated 'world of things'. This is what 'mind altering substances' - like the Tea beloved of the Pre-fab Four, as well as much stronger things like Schizophrenia (not recommended kids!) and also 'UFOs' potentially interfere with & disrupt, giving you your classic 'High Strangeness' experience.
The true 'Real' is separate from and exists outside language, thus cannot be symbolized.
'Real knowledge' is thus a similar impossibility since the 'Real' is impossible to imagine, thus cannot be symbolized or integrated into the Symbolic Order. This is why many, if not all of the current theories doing the rounds since the 70s can't be proved, disproved, verified, observed etc, etc. They're invariably abstract & 'elegant' models that make perfectly logical & symbolically mathematical sense.
Unfortunately, (as they're becoming increasingly aware) 'Reality' just isn't like that - 'Reality' is mind-bogglingly WEIRD (entanglement being an inexplicable & seemingly illogical example that drove Uncle Al Einstein round the bend) There is literally NO semblance of a theory that even begins to explain by what possible mechanism this instantaneously happens regardless of distance (violating Einstein's Speed of Light 'constant') so the 'UFOs violate classical physics & don't make any logical sense, therefore they don't/can't exist' is a ridiculously redundant argument!
Such basic, fundamental problems don't seem to have any bearing on your perspective. We can't even say for sure where a sub-atomic particle 'is' only where it's (probably) been or what 'Time' is or whether it even exists, never mind alternate realities/dimensions & whether they have some bearing on how 'entanglement' works (cos currently NO ONE has a clue) yet you inhabit this simplistic, 100% certain, black & white, nuts & bolts, true/false universe of classical physics which we all KNOW is merely a macro-illusion of perspective and NOT the mind-melting weird shit that's actually going on.
Fifty years later & Theoretical Physics has not progressed one bit! Now That's What I Call Pseudoscience (Vol. 198)
You are a comic. I'm beginning to appreciate why Rich treasures your posts. They're like an old black & white sit-com you've seen a hundred times but you still watch it. You know exactly what's coming next, it never changes, it's always the same but that's quite reassuring & entertaining at the same time. It exists in its own little timeless, unchanging bubble - unperturbed by the vexatious, fundamental uncertainties of Time, Gravity, Entanglement, even 'Reality' itself that Science still can't answer or get to grips with. None of this apparently bothers or concerns you anymore than it would Noddy driving hapilly through Toytown.
ANYTHING outside this little padded cell of mundanity is 'worthless mumbo jumbo' and must be stamped out immediately! Hahahaha. You are priceless.
Anyway put on some Rutles (I recommend 'Shabby Road' or 'Sgt. Rutter's Only Darts Club Band') stick some Tea in your non-existant pipe* & smoke it. (*© R. Magritte)
And remember - 'All You Need is Cash' (everybody..!)
By
DrDee, at Monday, July 16, 2018
When I go to sleep the whole universe disappears, when I awake it reassembles itself just for my observation. And you call me insignificant? Speak for yourself.
By
esp.philbrook, at Wednesday, July 18, 2018
A wee bit off topic, esp.philbrook.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, July 18, 2018
True, sorry. It was more a reply to a comment. Some, like mine, seem to be wandering. I totally agree with the main article.
By
esp.philbrook, at Thursday, July 19, 2018
Post a Comment
<< Home