UFO Conjectures

Tuesday, July 03, 2018

A (real) time-traveler?

Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.

The July 19, 2018 issue of The New York Review of Books has, on Page 38 ff., a review by Jim Holt of Oxford University’s new edition of Diogenes Laertius’ Lives of the Eminent Philosophers (translated from the Greek by Pamela Mensch). [676 pp. $45]

While the review and the book reviewed is particularly interesting to me, that’s not my concern here.

What I’m addressing is the compiler of the Lives, Diogenes Laertius.

Some of you are familiar with Michael Moorcock’s science-fiction work, Behold the Man in which a man, Karl Glogauer, travels back in time from 1970 to 28 A.D. hoping to meet Jesus of Nazareth:


(Use the link for the story.)

In the review of Lives …,, Mr. Holt tells readers that “almost nothing is known about [Diogenes Laertius]. Even his slightly absurd Greco-Roman name is a puzzle – was ‘Laertius’ some kind of nickname? Judging from the historical references in Lives … he probably lived early in the third century CE. There is a hint in his text that he might have been a native of the eastern city of Nicea. Beyond that he is a cipher. That his work would endure, when the vast majority of the philosophical writings he drew on perished, may simply have been a ‘quirk of fate’ – so guesses James Miller, the editor of this welcome new translation.” [Page 38]

Laertius as subject to much scholarly rebuke, Holt tells readers: “a ‘perfect ass’ … one nineteenth-century scholar called him. ‘Dim-witted’ said Nietzsche. And ‘ignoramus’ declared … Werner Jaeger … and he had ‘no talent for philosophical exposition,’ declares The Oxford Companion to Philosophy.” [ibid]

But Nietzsche, who [had] “cast scorn on Diogenes Laertius for his mindlessly slipshod ways, came to prefer his work to ‘the soporific fumes’ of more scholarly sources, because in it ‘there lives at least the spirit of the ancient philosophers.” [ibid]

Mr. Holt provides a bundle of excerpts from the work, which I recommend for those of you with a philosophical bent. (The review can be found online at NYRB.com)

What I’m driving at here is that Diogenes Laertius may have been a time traveler in the Moorcockian sense, a Karl Glogauer interested not in the Christ but the stellar thinkers of ancient Greece whose works were lost causing him to travel back in time to rectify that intellectual disaster.

That is, Diogenes Laertius was a name adopted by a traveler from time who, as a lover of the early Greek philosophies and their progenitors, was determined to go back to an era from which he could cull information about the books lost and the persons whom he adored.

(Now I know that a few of you will find this “conjecture” silly as hell but, for me, it is a possibility, as time will be conquered in the future, and travelers will scoot back and forth, under a directive that they do no harm.)

Wikipedia on Diogenes Laertius:


RR

3 Comments:

  • ->(Now I know that a few of you will find this “conjecture” silly as hell but, for me, it is a possibility, as time will be conquered in the future, and travelers will scoot back and forth, under a directive that they do no harm.) <-

    *
    (That they do no harm.)…

    BUT, the Paradox might! If one could go back in time, before they were born, then this would mean, that they "exist" before they "existed"

    Now, if one went forward into the future,"after their death" in this present reality
    they have just cheated death!! ..Mmmm!?.. How does this thing work....?

    By Blogger Daniel, at Wednesday, July 04, 2018  

  • It doesn't matter when a time traveler starts his or her journey. They all travel back and take their actions in the same moment in the past. For example, they all go back to the same November 22, 1963.

    If all of their actions occurred on November 22, 1963, then, because time is linear by nature, all of those actions are knowable by a person sitting at the vantage point of 2018. So we have to assume that, no matter how many future time travelers go back to that day, they all failed to save John Kennedy. All their actions have already been accounted for in our present knowledge of a past event.

    By Blogger Voidoid, at Monday, July 09, 2018  

  • Thus, the main events, are "LOCKED" in time!...

    Although, time travellers, may move through time, and nothing more, than just, time travel.....

    By Blogger Daniel, at Thursday, July 19, 2018  

Post a Comment

<< Home