Another Reality (or Realities) from which UFOs (and other Anomalist things) come?
Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.
And can we access other alleged realities?
The August 10, 2018 issue of TLS (The
Literary Supplement) reviewed the two books I noted a few weeks back from The
New York Review of Books [Michael Pollan’s How to Change Your Mind:The
new science of psychedelics and Tao Lin’s Trip].
My posting provoked some commentary, much from my pal,
academic Bryan Sentes, who, while fascinated by many things (UFOs among them),
seems inordinately gleamed by hallucinogenic substances: LSD, psilocybin (magic
mushrooms), Mescaline (a naturally occurring psychedelic alkaloid), et
cetera.
Bryan also suggested that I read The Road to Eleusis:
Unveiling the Secret of the Mysteries by R. Gordon Wasson, Albert
Hofmann, and Carla P. Ruck which I bought and am slogging my way through, and
which I posted a note about earlier here.
Interestingly, the August 10 TLS also had, from
its archive, reviews of two Aldous Huxley books, The Doors of Perception
(reviewed February 19, 1954) and Heaven and Hell (reviewed March 9,
1956) both examined by Hugh I’Anson Fausset.
The Fausset reviews are pertinent to this posting as they go to the heart of what we may perceive under the influence of
hallucinogenics, according to Aldous Huxley (Brave New World).
Huxley, it seems, like Bryan Sentes, was prone to be
enthused by the possibilities of accessing another reality (or realities) by
the ingesting of mescaline that the early “Indians of Mexico and American
southwest have eaten and venerated [from] the root of a cactus, which they called peyotl [peyote]
and regarded as a divine intoxicant.” [TLS, Page 34]
The reviewer (Fausset), writing in the 50s, noted that “more
recently psychologists have become interested in it, since some of the
changes in consciousness which it caused were similar to those which occur in
schizophrenia.” [ibid, italics, mine]
Huxley, the reviewer told readers, believed that “Our modern
recognition that living on the surface of the mind, caged in rational
self-consciousness, is no real defence against the hidden forces in our nature
[and] has started a whole movement of exploration of the deeper levels of the
psyche … “ [ibid]
And “the Interest of Mr. Huxley’s essay, however, lies in the correspondences which he traces between the kind of ‘other world’ perceived under mescalin and the records of visionary experience preserved in all the cultural traditions in the heavens and fairylands of folklore and religion …” [ibid]
And “the Interest of Mr. Huxley’s essay, however, lies in the correspondences which he traces between the kind of ‘other world’ perceived under mescalin and the records of visionary experience preserved in all the cultural traditions in the heavens and fairylands of folklore and religion …” [ibid]
“Almost never does the visionary see anything that reminds
him of his own past. He is not remembering scenes, persons, or objects, and he
is not inventing them; he is looking at a new creation.” [ibid; I disagree
with this.]
“But the kindred hells of the schizophrenic suggest how big
a part subjective fantasy can play in this kind of experience. To an unwanted
imagination it must be at best be a realm of fascinating illusion.” [ibid,
really?]
The above, considering Mr. Huxley’s views, is typical of how
some hallucinogenic advocates see the use of such “drugs”: schizophrenics are
mad (insane) but users of hallucinogens, and what they perceive, are glorious
visions of the greater reality (or realities) that exist and which they can
access under hallucinogenic intoxication. [Posh!]
There seems to be intrusions into our “normal” reality –
Nick Redfern examples many in his writings and books. But those are observed
(experienced) by non-drug users usually.
I happen to think, as you know, that schizophrenics may have
or get access to other realities which psychiatrists keep insisting are mad
fantasies but may very well be perceptions of an actual reality (or realities)
that a “schizophrenic” for some odd neurological reason is afflicted by and
really sees and/or hears.
Let me propose this: if a person reports a UFO sighting, and
we determine that the person is mentally healthy, we’d pretty much accept his or
her observation (report) as bona fide, would we not?
But if we found out that the “witness” was under the influence
of alcohol or LSD (or some other psychedelic or hallucinogenic material), would
we be likely to accept their observation (report) as authentic, accurate? I
think not.
But if a schizophrenic tells us that they saw a UFO and
described it, along with a batch of mentally corrupt accretions (memories and
fantasies), would we accept their observation as valid and true” Probably not.
But we shouldn’t, I think, discard it out of hand.
Madness induced observations may be the real doorway to
other realities, whereas the hallucinations of the Eleusinians (who used ergot,
an hallucinogenic fungus) or the mental waywardness of an alcoholic or
hallucinogenic user is suspect, as I see it.
Mr. Huxley, as much as I admire his works (Antic Hay,
Chrome Yellow, The Devils of Loudon, Island, and those named above), was on
the wrong path, about perceptions of a greater or other reality, just as my
buddy, Bryan Sentes, is wrong about the use of hallucinogens, except maybe as a
medicinal aide for the terminally ill.
RR


11 Comments:
Rich, I find it interesting that others, you?, casually throw in schizophrenia as those having and esoteric pathway to human consciousness. From a clinical point of view, schizophrenia is multifaceted in its affect on perception of reality. The schizophrenics perception of reality is distorted abhorrently is some cases. Whats ignored in your posting is the affects of the positive and negative traits and each traits level of severity. From what I seen and dealt with firsthand, I'm afraid that schizophrenia is not the gateway to the Gods, UFOs, ET and other paranormal claptrap.
Frankly this is the type of stuff that I would be treated to listening to Coast to Coast on the car radio heading home after work. How ironic that a psychiatric nurse would listen to delusional accountings on the radio after spending part of the day dealing with the real thing!
By
Tim Hebert, at Tuesday, August 28, 2018
Your view, Tim, of schizophrenia is short-sighted, and I know you deal with the matter daily.
The persons listed as schizophrenic when I was privileged to deal with them during my Abnormal Psych bout, noted by media way back when, were, as I keep noting here, not just removed from our (normal) reality but privy, it seemed to me, to something more.
Inside the all the corrupting influences of their malfunctioning neurons were residue of something not quite amenable to psychiatric understanding.
And neurological studies have not been able to fathom those insertions of odd remnants that do not have the earmarks of insanity, as Oliver Sacks came to delineate in his last offerings and my son Josh's neurological (current) texts show.
You write "The schizophrenics perception of reality is distorted abhorrently" which is true but then there is something else at work.
I'm not asserting that schizophrenics have access to the gods or a real other reality, but I am suggesting that madness may have access to realities different from our (normal) reality and that access should be studied seriously.
It isn't now, as most mentally afflicted persons are treated with mind-numbing drugs smothering any chance of finding out just exactly what it is that they are perceiving inside the cloud of mental turmoil they've accumulated, often exacerbated by medicines that do more harm than good.
You are off the mark and misunderstand my views, opting to put them in a category that is far from what I've offered in the posting above and elsewhere.
The pursuit of schizophrenia is and has been superficial and pathetic.
Need I provide citations?
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Tuesday, August 28, 2018
You'll have to excuse my remarks in the context of your post. I tend to become annoyed, not angry, that UFO buffs tend to use the schizophrenia card haphazardly without knowing the components of the condition. Of all the psychiatric cases that I deal with I enjoy working with the schizophrenic and it's variations. Borderline personalities are the absolute worst and this may be more prevalent in Ufology.
By
Tim Hebert, at Wednesday, August 29, 2018
Ah, those borderline personalities.
I just had three try to comment in this blog, one about a 2012 posting.
Give me a schizophrenic any time over a UFO "nut."
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, August 29, 2018
Where to begin...
1. I'm hardly "gleamed [sic] by hallucinogenic substances": I merely offer an evidence-based complement to your dogmatic dismissal of said substances. I do admit, however, to being sympathetic to research into the therapeutic potential of psychedelics/entheogens (including PTSD, depression, and addiction), their spiritual potential, and aspects of the literature that touch on matters ufological. (Future such misrepresentations of my stated positions will be referred to my solicitor!).
2. To depend on reviews of two of Huxley's works from the 50s is pretty tenuous. In general, Huxley is canonical in the psychedelic literature, along with many others, whose number is growing, so his views are increasingly supplemented, complemented, and relativized. What is dated, though, are the posited analogues between schizophrenia and a state of LSD intoxication, a position long since been disavowed, indeed within a decade of these reviews being written.
3. You disagree that "the visionary sees [nothing] that reminds him of his own past. He is not remembering scenes, persons, or objects, and he is not inventing them; he is looking at a new creation." On what basis? A curious dimension of the Ayahuasca/Yage experience is its consistency across subjects of varying backrounds, consistent with other research that has been claimed to confirm Jung's Collective Unconscious, or at least a species-specific resevoir of symbols. See _The Antipodes of the Mind: Charting the Phenomenology of the Ayahuasca Experience_, Benny Shanon, Oxford University Press, 2002.
4. Your dismissal of the psychedelic experience as mere "posh" (sic) is simply uninformed: the literature reveals there is no distinguishing an "authentic" mystical experience from one induced entheogenically, as the Good Friday Experiment was the first show, and not the last.
Your point seems to be that 1) IF there are "alternate realities" where UFOs etc originate, and 2) IF it is possible for us to access these realities that seem to access our own (talk about "conjectures"!), then 3) schizophrenia may offer access to these realities but psychedelics not.
Has anyone claimed psychedelics give access to an alternate reality? You seem to take the reviewer's take of Huxley as claiming so. But it seems a far-fetched reading of Huxley, given even the reviewer puts the words "other world" in quotation marks: Huxley here refers to the radically altered perceptions psychedelics induce.
That being said, I do know, however, of one culture whose members annually gather and ingest Peyote and that, within this highly regulated ritual setting and on the basis of deep cultural roots, say they enter a paradisal realm, Wirikuta. Moreover, among those researching DMT (a substance present in all animals and plants), Rick Strassmam (a documentary version of his book _The Spirit Molecule_ is viewable on YouTube), like John Mack, has raised the _question_ of the reality of the entities encountered during DMT sessions and alien abductions, respectively. To my knowledge maybe only Terrance McKenna ever affirmed the reality (he called it "Hyperspace") of the Machine Elves he encountered on DMT.
In general, I have a hard time imagining someone disagreeing that someone under the influence of a psychedelic is not a trustworthy witness of a class of events (e.g., an anomalous event, such as the O'Hare Airport sighting of 7 November 2006) given their mental and perceptual state. That being said, there is evidence of augmented creative and even cognitive abilities under the influence of psychedelics, both anecdotal and more formal (see Harman et al."Psychedelic Agents in Creative Problem Solving: A Pilot Study", _Psychological Reports_ 19, (1966): 211-217).
If I were to venture a conclusion here it would be that you're knocking down a strawman here.
By
Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, August 29, 2018
Ah, but the strawman gets so much attention....
You provide a salvo of supporting materials for your view(s) Bryan, that's why I admire you, but in every supporting offering there seems to be a cautionary wariness to commit to an all-out endorsement of the hallucinogenic inducements.
I think, as we should do with UFOs, that we gather an accumulation of "data" (things perceived) to see if there are commonalities, certain things that show up as constants, or if what is perceived is unique to the individual(s) perceiving.
I don't think that has been done, except in your mention of the Ayahuasca/Yage experience. Is there an account of the "vision(s)" seen and a comparison with the analogs distributed by Jung in his presentation of archetypes from the Collective Unconscious; e.g., the mandala?
I'll have more to write about this, citing many of the Rosales examples as providing a batch of information that can be collated, as they say.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Wednesday, August 29, 2018
I'm unsure if I understand your point here.
_Who_ pays so much attention to the strawman (i.e., that "psychedelics open access to other realities"? assuming we can even make sense of that question)? Some members of an ill-defined, very large and variegated psychedelic community? Myself? I am unaware of any researchers or explorers I would take seriously who do; and the examples of Wirikuta and DMT (Strassman and Terrance McKenna) were provided only to orient the discussion toward not unrelated, real world examples.
As to that accumulation of data you ask for: on the one hand, human experience with entheogens goes back to probably even before homo sapiens. The earliest religion is shamanism, which, in some (that is the logical "some": one or all but one of a class...) varieties, availed itself of Plant Teachers (including the pre-Indo European religion of Greece, if Wasson et al. are to be believed). The West, after the millennia-long suppressions of Christianity, "Reason", and legalistic prohibition, is only now learning of this inheritance and investigating the matter, which is still made nigh-impossible because of the ignorant drug laws in many countries where the research is trying to be carried out.
A sample of the research, still in its infancy, can, for example, be found here http://psychedelicscience.org/videos (over 100 presentations delivered at 2017's Psychedelic Science conference: two of my favourite presenters are Stanislav Grof and Gabor Mate).
This research at least often has the advantage of reproducibility, unlike research in ufology, where we only have sighting reports (as Hynek quipped to Vallee).
By
Bryan Sentes, at Thursday, August 30, 2018
But Bryan, the "evidence" for the paradisical experience of psychedelic (hallucinogenic) "drug" users comes from the persons experiencing the so-called other reality themselves, much like UFO witnesses offering their experience via reports.
I'm sure you will be able to find many obscure and advocational reports favoring the use or experimentation of the hallucinogens you like.
But the cultish approach to using the "drugs" reminds me of the practices of the early Gnostic Christians (more than interesting to me) that remains arcane or esoteric to almost everyone, and thus meaningless in the normal scheme of things.
The link to the 2017 Psychedelic Science Conference you offer also has the taste of those UFO conferences where UFO kooks promulgate their nonsense.
Anyway, I applaud your devotion to the practice and use of hallucinogens.
It's cute in its way, and so 1960ish.
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Thursday, August 30, 2018
Your resistance to the evidence in this matter is like that of so-called educated people to the topic of UFOs.
To compare a learned conference attended by _professional_ scholars, scientists and researchers to a UFO conference is, to use your word, crackpot. A quick perusal of the more than one hundred lectures would find that most if not all use the quantifiable research methods, physical (e.g., fMRI) and statistical, characteristic of research in these fields.
If I have any devotion, it is to evidence, argument, and inquiry.
By
Bryan Sentes, at Thursday, August 30, 2018
Okay, smart guy...
I actually pay attention to your suggestions and links. more than you may know.
I'm just giving you a rough time about the hallucinogens as my experience with persons who use them or used them has been enlightening.
They always end up conversing and thinking like morons....yes. They have never indicated one iota of transformational enlightenment, just the ramifications of sexual activity they engaged in while "under."
A violin virtuoso friend of mine, who liked to use various enhancements in the category under discussion, once asked me to accompany him, on the piano, for a playing of Massenet's Thais "Meditation" -- which I kept botching up.
A few days later he went to the mountains and committed suicide.
Did I botch up the piece too much for his enlightened demeanor or did he finally succumb to the other reality which he experienced and found better that the reality here.
I don't know, but that's only one example of what I have seen among the LSD, marijuana, mushroom crowd.
Your enthusiasm for everything makes me discount the idea that you are a warped advocate of LSD, mushroom use.
I'm thinking you might read Oliver Sacks last few writings about his use of such "medicinals" -- and you know how he died, and from what, yes?
RR
By
RRRGroup, at Thursday, August 30, 2018
Given your personal experience, your reservations and resistance are more understandable.
By
Bryan Sentes, at Thursday, August 30, 2018
Post a Comment
<< Home