UFO Conjectures

Tuesday, August 21, 2018

The Eleusinian Mysteries and Ufology: Two crackpot doctrinaire activities

Copyright 2018, InterAmerica Inc.

I haven’t received a book that my pal Bryan Sentes recommended about the early Greek mystery (cultish) rite known as The Eleusis Mystery that certain philosophers practiced [Plato, Aristotle, Iamblichus, and Proclus, among them].

But I have a slew of books that reference the practice and none indicate a favorable tone as the book Bryan recommended is said to do.

The Eleusis rite, as obscure as it seems to be, reminds me of the hazy practice of UFO research and study, ufology, which is the haven of “mystagogy” practiced by hordes of inept researchers and ETH ideologues.

A reference for those seeking a concise, objective account of The Eleusis Mysteries is The Classical Tradition [Editors Grafton. Most, Settis, The Belnap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2010, Page 613].

For those seeking an objective concise rendering of Ufological nonsense can find it in the blog writings of Zoam Chomsky [aka Aaron Sakulich] or French skeptic, cognitive psychologist Gilles Fernandez.

The Eleusis Mystery rite has been taken apart by various scholars [Wind, 1958] and reactivated by others [Hadot, 2006], and my pal Bryan, a poet foremost, applies heated support for the mysteries as they involved, allegedly, psychedelics: ergot, an hallucinogenic fungus.

Bryan would, I think, use Aristotle’s statement – “… those who enter initiations do not learn anything, but experience something” to promote the use of psychedelics and pursuit for the face of god, which is the underlying point of psychedelicism and the arcane mysteries apparently.

I should note that Martin Heidegger and the Nazis (whom he supported) were fervently into the Eleusis Mysteries.

Ufology has the feverous flavor of those advocating psychedelics. It (ufology) is rampant with advocates of an underlying “truth” that is hidden from view but can be accessed by the rituals of ornate debate and mystagogic ramblings.

For them, the UFO truth can be discoverd by a hardened ritual of information mangling, as one finds in the commentary about Roswell.

Ufology has its secretive masters: Keel, Friedman, Vallee, Bigelow, and DeLonge. And those have their initiates and followers.

It’s the blind leading the blind, as was the case with the early Eleusinian initiates and followers.

As Professor Wind excoriated those “who embraced mystagogic rites … succumb[ing] to hocus-pocus” [op.cit., 613], I wish to denigrate those in the UFO community who continue to see Roswell as the fount of UFO truth, setting aside any kind of reasoned thought about the phenomenon.

They are as dizzy as the Eleusian initiates and the modern day users of hallucinogenics.

RR 

2 Comments:

  • I'm heading back to teaching today after a two-year hiatus, so if I'm a little pedantic, I apologize in advance.

    If I understand you, you take up two-ish topics here: 1) the Eleusianian Mysteries as such, a religious ritual conducted every September in the region of Eleusis for about 4,000 years, and whose mystery (the revelation revealed to participants and the rite leading to that revelation) remains, well, a mystery, because of the strict code of silence adhered to by initiates, who included many of the major figures of classical antiquity, the tragedians, Plato, Aristotle, etc., and 2) the mystery of the Eleusinian Mysteries, i.e., the unknown nature of the ritual.

    ONE attempt to solve the mystery of the Mysteries (namely problem (2)) is _The Road to Eleusis_ by Wasson, et al. It proposes, in line with one of the co-author's theses developed in other volumes as well, that the rite involved the use of a psychedelic.

    In as much as there is an insoluble historical mystery here, and one investigated by serious scholars and less-serious folk (you would call "crackpots"), the mystery of the Mysteries surely bears analogies to ufology. That being said, and I've made this point before, just because a topic attracts crackpots, doesn't entail the topic itself is crackpot nor that all who involve themselves in said topic are crackpots; the topic of quantum gravity is a good example.

    Aside from that, I must take exception to your writing that I apply "heated support for the mysteries as they involved, allegedly, psychedelics: ergot, an hallucinogenic fungus." I only ever raised the example of the Mysteries to counter your admittedly dogmatic rejection of all things entheogenic; my counterproposal is that entheogens and other means of evoking varieties of religious experience seem a universal aspect of human culture, and one practiced and looked into by some its finest minds. (It occurred to me yesterday I should be more energetic in my remiding you of Freud's own explorations into another mind-altering substance, cocaine, not to mention his persistent smoking of tobbacco...)

    I'm tempted to question the thesis that Heidegger was "fervently into the Eleusis [sic] Mysteries", that Jacques Vallee is a "secretive master", and your unwarranted dismissal of all those serious researchers into psychedelics, but that would be an aside to my defending my fairly consistently clearly stated postions from your own "information mangling"...

    You know as well as I do, that it is precisely the crackpottery around the UFO question (some of it arguabley intentionally cultured) that makes investigating its physical nature (if it has one) anathema and that has led Jacques Vallee to abandon the field, at least publicly. But that too, the taboo around the topic, is itself grist for the scholarly-investigative mill...

    By Blogger Bryan Sentes, at Wednesday, August 22, 2018  

  • Bryan...

    You, as usual, do the topic well.

    The book you recommended will arrive today (8/22) and I may have to tone down my polemic, but until then, I stand firmly on my views, first that Freud's use of cocaine was medicinal, mostly, and second that some topics attract crackpots, Why?

    I will have more on the mysteries and the scourge of stupid people in ufology, upcoming.

    RR

    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Wednesday, August 22, 2018  

Post a Comment

<< Home