Being knowledgeable about UFOs (and Roswell?)
A new novel by Zia Haider Rahman, In the Light of What We
Know [Farrar, Straus & Giroux], deals with who gets to be called
“educated,” and why.
James Wood reviews the work for The New Yorker [May 19,
2014, The World As We Know It: Zia Haider Rahman’s dazzling debut, Page 87 ff.]
Author Rahman indicates “that we know much less than we
think we do, that intellectual modesty in the face of mystery and complexity
may be the surest wisdom.” [Page 87]
“Knowledge is what we have to go through, what we have to
consume, in order to be finally consumed – in order to understand how little we
knew.” [ibid]
Rahman found at Oxford, where he attended, that “knowledge
was just ‘a social act’ … and the men and women there were merely inflating
what the knew ‘to fill the voids’” because “the root of true, rightly guided
power, the essence of authority, was not learning but the veneer of knowledge.”
[Page 91]
(Much like what we find in comments here and at such venues
as Kevin Randle’s blog.)
Rahman continues with “All of us, grave or light, get our
thoughts entangled in metaphors, and act fatally on the strength of them.”
[Page 92]
Metaphors “have their place … but ‘never as explanations,
never as substitute for the thing itself, which is the only thing that can turn
on the lights or leave us in the dark.’” [Page 98]
(That statement addresses the UFO problem.)
“Mathematician[s] also distrust metaphors, and … they never
tell you what actually happened, ‘how it happened, or why it happened … if
metaphors increase our understanding, they do so only because they take us back
to a familiar vantage, which is to say that a metaphor cannot bring anything
nearer.” [Page 98]
“… the novel uses Gödel’s theorem …employing it as a mantra,
an image, a Platonic picture: there is truth somewhere, but not for us now.”
[Page 98]
And to give comfort to ufologists and UFO ET believers,
reviewer Wood tells readers that the novel’s character, Zafar, is “obsessed
with … Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem:
Within any given system, there are claims which are true but
which cannot be proven to be true.” [Page 91]
That should salve Anthony Bragalia, David Rudiak, Nick
Redfern, and even the fringe paranormalists all over the place.
RR
