UFO Conjectures

Saturday, September 02, 2017

UFOs and The AI [Artificial Intelligence] Dilemma

Copyight 2017, InterAmerica, Inc.
My Canadian pal, Bryan Sentes, is a philosophy scholar, having won accolades in the field, and poet who teaches at  Dawson College and is currently dealing with some serious health issues.

He is the most erudite person I personally know.

He presented a link on his Facebook page about AI and the dangers it seems to pose according to transhumanists.

Bryan conflates the AI discussion with brilliant philosophical asides and references to the current thinking about consciousness, intelligence, and thought in its broadest senses.

This caught my eye and brought me to an ongoing back-and-forth with Bryan September 1 and 2, until we (mostly me) had run the topic into the ground.

My views and knowledge of AI are simplistic, as many of you know from my postings here, but I am fairly well read on the matter, and Bryan chose to accommodate my pathetic views, some of which I’ll present here (again).

The current primary AI advocates (who see dangers looming in “machine intelligence) include Elon Musk, Stephen Hawking, Bill Gates, Nick Bostrom, Ray Kurzweil (perhaps), and a few others.

The grand old man of AI was Marvin Minsky (now deceased) "who believed that there is no fundamental difference between humans and machines, and that humans are machines whose 'intelligence' emerges from the interplay of the many unintelligent but semi-autonomous agents that comprise the brain." [From Wikipedia]
Minsky is rarely referred to today but his views are those that I find the most palatable and savory.

And Minsky is my cover when I suggest that some UFOs are AI machines that have evolved from or are tools of an advanced extraterrestrial species which have stumbled upon Earth in the past and continue to reconnoiter to this day.

I’ve cited a few UFO cases that stand out, for me, as suggestive of AI interference:

The 1948 Gorman UFO “dogfight,” the 1954 Marius Dewilde episode in France, the 1967 Stefan Michalak/Falcon Lake incident, and the 1979 Robert Taylor “assault” in Scotland. [There are others.]
Bryan sees little chance that machines have intelligence as we understand intelligence but I won’t debase his views with my lack of understanding of them.

However, keeping the matter rather simple, as is my wont, when you view the sightings mentioned above, one sees (from the witness reports, which is all we have) that the UFOs or entities involved appeared to be behaving as if they were re-active, responding intelligently.

One could suggest that the perceived “intelligence” was projected upon the UFOs or the entities by the witnesses, and we know that’s a viable psychological possibility.

But I think UFO witnesses are fairly accurate in their reporting and observations with a few caveats about minor details. And, overall, in the cases noted. the witnesses recorded or remembered their experiences rather accurately. I get the feeling that what they observed was imbued with a kind of reactive intelligence.

Bryan dismisses sentience in machines (computers, robots, et cetera), but I’ve written here that some machines seem to have feelings or act as if they do. (That is fluffy and I have to concede that Bryan’s views are much more sensible than mine, as one would expect.)

But in the UFO cases, I’ve cited, there does appear to have been intelligent behavior on the part of the UFOs or machine-like entities involved.

While I don’t think aliens [ETs] have been visiting Earth in droves, I do allow that an advanced species, either AI machines or beings that use them, may have stumbled upon our diverse and interesting planet and, perhaps, have returned or called for further examination of us with AI UFOs.

This doesn’t resolve the AI controversy that Bryan is attuned to and understands better than most but it, I hope, shows you why I insist upon bringing up the topic here and think that the “transhumanists” Bryan deplores are prescient to be wary of evolving AI machines (robots, computers, even our iPhones?).

(I’ll try to cull some of Bryan’s Facebook comments and present them, upcoming, here so those of you interested in AI and its possible UFO context can weigh in.)

[Image at top from ZDNet] 

RR