UFO Conjectures

Thursday, July 30, 2020

That 1979 Robert Taylor incident causes hic-cups on Facebook

Copyright 2020, InterAmerica, Inc.

After I noted, at Facebook, that this blog was now “private” (and explained why), I dropped a few lines about the 1979 Robert Taylor incident that was discussed here at length a while back.
A few FB UFOers took umbrage at my view that the event was an example of a Temporal Lobe Epilepsy seizure (as suggested by Patricia Hannaford according to Wikipedia) and not an attack by some elaborate UFO machinery as some UFO researchers have it.

I wanted Mr. Taylor’s event to be an AI encounter; that is, a con- frontation with an other-reality machine (extraterrestrial, other-dimensional machine, or something from another time and place perhaps).

But the TLE literature makes clear to me that Mr. Taylor had an epileptic seizure (like one he had previously, according to Malcolm Robinson).

Here are the symptoms of a TLE; compare them to the incident details from Mr. Taylor’s account and the follow-up by researchers:
The hard-core supporters of the UFO explanation are entrenched and don’t seem to have digested or read the TLE literature online (and presented below, here).

RR

Temporal lobe epilepsy: origin and significance of simple and complex auras

DAVID C TAYLOR, MOIRA LOCHERY
From the University Department of Psychiatry

The study of aura has a respectable history since the introduction of the term by Pelops, the master of Galen,3 to describe the "breath of air" which was his patient's premonition of a seizure. Reported auras seem stable between cultures and over historical time.

Bernard of Gordon's patient reported "a confusion in the head, and a darkness in the eyes" (1 542)4 and Gastaut etal (1959)5 "a black fog before the eyes".

Persinger:

[Religious oriented temporal lobe epilepsy]


Anatomical origin of d??j?? vu and vivid 'memories' in human temporal lobe epilepsy
Article in Brain · March 1994
DOI: 10.1093/brain/117.1.71 · Source: PubMed

As Jackson had also observed, the dreamy state could occur alone but was often associated with epigastric phenomena and fear, and followed by loss of contact and oro-alimentary automatisms, and then by simple gestural automatisms, all characteristic of partial seizures beginning in the medial temporal lobe. Furthermore, as also emphasized by Jackson the dreamy state was seldom associated with sensory illusions.

Patient 13:

described after habitual seizures, a feeling of strangeness and unreality of the environment, with the feeling of dija vicu that he could not better describe. Questioning during an evoked seizure revealed that this 'dija vicu' corresponded to a sudden memory of a very elaborate scene. During another seizure, provoked by stimu- lation of the same structure, and with the same electrographic evolution, the same patient could only report a feeling of strangeness of the environment.

References:

Ferguson SM, Rayport M, Gardner R, Kass W, Weiner H, Reiser MF. Similarities in mental content of psychotic states, spontaneous seizures, dreams, and responses to electrical brain stimulation in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. Psychosom Med 1969; 31: 478-98.

Gloor P, Olivier A, Quesney LF. The role of the amygdala in the expression of psychic phenomena in temporal lobe seizures. In: Ben-Ari Y, editor. The amygdaloid complex. Amsterdam: Elsevier/North-Holland Biomedical Press, 1981: 489-98.

Penfield W. The role of the temporal cortex in certain psychical phenomena. J Ment Sci 1955; 101: 451-65.

Penfield W, Perot P. The brain's record of auditory and visual experience: a final summary and discussion. Brain 1963; 86: 595-696.

Schneider RC, Crosby EC, Bagchi BK, Calhoun HD. Temporal or occipital lobe hallucinations triggered from frontal lobe lesions.
Neurology 1961; 11: 72-9.

PSYCHICAL PHENOMENA IN TEMPORAL LOBE EPilEPSY AND TIE PSYCHOSES*
BY
SHAFICA KARAGULLA, MiD., M.R.C.P.Ed.
D.P.M.
Department of Neurology and Neurosurgery, McGill
University and Montreal Neurological Institute
AND
E. ELIZABETH ROBERTSON, M.B., F.R.C.P.Ed.
D.P.M.
Royal Edinburgh Hospital for Mental and Nervous
Disorders

The experiences which we describe and illustrate may be stated thus: (1) The experiencing of " thoughts "-such thoughts being either indefinite or formulated. (2) The hearing of " voices " within the mind or body or from a point external to the self. (3) The seeing of persons, objects, or scenes,  which, again, may be perceived within the mind or at some point external to the self.

[The patient] fell down during the attack and tried to overcome it by mental effort, whereupon he was aware of all his thoughts transforming themselves into vivid external visual images. He was so terrified by this that he kept changing his thoughts, but each thought continued to transform itself into a visual image. For instance, he thought of fire-crackers, and suddenly these were seen in sunset colours of blue and mauve in front of his eyes located "about a block away," seeming to tumble down through the sky but never reaching him. Then he thought of a space ship, and it appeared as a pinkish-blue object, moving towards him, becoming smaller as it did so.

Semiologic and Electrophysiologic Correlations in Temporal Lobe
Seizure Subtypes
†Louis Maillard, †Jean-Pierre Vignal, Martine Gavaret, Maxime Guye, ‡Arnaud Biraben,
Aileen McGonigal, Patrick Chauvel, and Fabrice Bartolomei

Sensory illusions and hallucinations:

In this study, as previously proposed (33,34), we separated pure sensory illusions or hallucinations from vivid hallucinations, vivid recollections of scenes, and from the sensation of d´ej`a-vu.

Psychosis in epilepsy patients
Siddhartha Nadkarni, Vanessa Arnedo, and Orrin Devinsky

Epileptic psychoses reflect a fundamental disruption in the fidelity of mind and occur during seizure freedom or during or after seizures. The psychotic symptoms in epilepsy share some qualities with schizophrenic psychosis, such as positive symptoms of paranoid delusions and hallucinations. Psychotic syndromes in epilepsy are most common but not exclusively associated with temporal lobe epilepsy.

ICTAL PSYCHOSIS

Ictal psychosis is rare: cognitive, affective, and hallucinatory symptoms of partial epilepsy combine to produce a psychotic state (Wells, 1975).Most partial seizures last under 3 min, and the psychic symptoms evoked during such transient spells rarely cause symptoms that would be considered psychotic. Ictal psychosis relates most commonly to visual or auditory illusions and hallucinations combined with affective changes, such as agitation or fear or paranoia.

Other psychic phenomena of partial epilepsy include deper- sonalization, derealization, autoscopy, out of body experience, or a sense of “someone behind.” These ictal experiential phenomena most often localize to the temporal lobe with activation of limbic and neocortical temporal areas. Prolonged ictal psychotic states are rare…