The madness of science
Copyright 2018, InterAmerica, Inc.
Reviews of four science books, by Samuel Graydon in the May
18, 2018 issue of TLS [Times Literary Supplement],
provides an example of the current insanity that pretends to be science.
The books – Special Relativity and Classical Field Theory:
The Theoretical Minimum by Leonard Susskind and Art Friedman
[Allen Lane], The Little Book of Black Holes by Steven S. Gubser and
Frans Pretorius [Princeton University Press], The Order of Time by Carlo
Rovelli [Allen Lane], Conjuring the Universe: The Origins of the
Laws of Nature by Peter Atkins [Oxford University Press – are
succinctly reviewed by Mr. Graydon, a TLS editor.
Either Mr. Graydon is deficient in current physical thinking
or the authors of the books reviewed are part of the current mish-mash of crazy
views that inhabit astrophysics, theoretical physics, cosmology, and every
other kind of physics that have become de rigueur in academia and the
science.
The reason I write this is that the ideas presented are
nutty, open-ended, and even schizophrenic. Let me example…
The Susskind/Friedman book are, Mr. Graydon writes, …”very
hard to understand … certainly if you are not strongly mathematically minded.”
You know from previous postings here that Astrophysics was
my first major in college, a major I eschewed because of my disdain for the
ballyhooed Big Bang theory and the austere stance of my fellow students and
professors who used math as the lingua franca of class sessions.
They flaunted math like Catholic priests and The Church used
Latin to keep parishioners in the dark and Ancient Alien theorists use
hieroglyphics to flummox those they are trying to convince of early
extraterrestrial visitors to Earth.
Math is the province of science, especially physicists, who
want to keep common humans away from their esoteric and abstruse ideas, which
is what Susskind and Friedman do in their book.
Gubser and Pretorious – remember, Dr. Pretorious was the
crazy doctor who helped Henry [sic] Frankenstein in The Bride of
Frankenstein movie, but our Pretorious is not him – have written, Graydon
says, “ … a surprisingly dry book” in which they state, “… if you were to fly a
spaceship to the inner horizon of a spinning black hole … [the spaceship] would
be able to ‘see’ the entire infinite time evolution of the outside universe!”
How do they know this? How does anyone know this? This is
conjecture far more mad than anything found here or in ufology.
Carlo Rovelli, dealing with time, writes there is no “now”
no “present” nor any past or future. Graydon notes Rovelli’s thesis thus, “They
[now, present, past, future] are not distinguishable from each other in any of
the basic equations of the world except one: ΔS≥0 …[which] is the second law of thermodynamics” [that indicates]
heat passes only from hot bodies to cold; never the other way around.”
“Heat passes one way, from hot to cold and not vice versa.
The fact that it is irreversible distinguishes a difference between before and
after. And, as heat is nothing but a disordering, it is this mixing that
distinguishes the past and future.”
Really?
Rovelli is glib, and reviewer Grayson notes that “In a
microscopic description [as one finds in Quantum Mechanics] there can be no
sense in which the past is different than the future.”
There we have it: In Quantum theory, there is the
possibility that the past and future can be accessed, and those of you
following the latest thinking in Quantum Mechanics, the math (the reality)
allows for quantum to be applicable in the macro world, as it is in the micro
world.
So Rovelli has limited his views, applying them
discriminately, not profoundly.
Peter Atkins, Graydon writes, “ … explores the laws of
physics … but instead of simply stating the laws, he approaches them
thematically, meanders, wraps them up in biography and sometimes strays off
topic [like many commenters here], so that occasionally one loses sight of what
is and what isn’t one of the governing principles of the universe.”
But I like that “Atkins’ hypothesis is that ‘nothing much’
happened at the beginning of the universe … that not only did ‘not much’ happen
at the Creation but ‘that the ‘not much’ was nothing at all.” [My position at
WSU when I left Astrophysics for Psychology.]
My point, in all this, is that physics (science altogether)
is as loopy as ufology, maybe even loopier.
Madness is rampant almost everywhere. And that’s why when
one invokes science as a rebuff to certain musings by UFO buffs, me included, I
scoff.
RR

