UFO Conjectures

Wednesday, May 27, 2020

Artificial Intelligence [AI] is not artificial at all

Copyright 2020, InterAmerica, Inc.

I posted a link, the other day, to the 5/15/20 TLS [Times Literary Supplement] review by Tim Crane of Brian Cantwell Smith’s The Promise of Artificial Intelligence [MIT Press, $24.95]: Com- puters Don’t Give a Damn

The reviewer is Professor of Philosophy at the Central European University and Philosophy editor of TLS. Author Cantwell Smith is a scholar in the fields of cognitive science, computer science, infor- mation studies, and philosophy, especially ontology.


The review irked me, even though I have no capacity to differ with the views of the reviewer or author.

I’m irked by the “conclusion” of both: that AI can never think like human beings, AI unable to provide the intelligence inherent to mankind.

The problem for me is that AI is not meant not to mimic human intelligence, which is marred by emotional input and output, as psychologists have demonstrated vibrantly since the formulations of Freud, Jung, and the composite of psychological insights since the origins of psychoanalysis and other schools of psychological schools of thought.

Smith and his reviewer Crane would push the idea that AI needs the constraints of judgment in order to be labeled “intelligent.”

I disagree, as do many advocates of present day AI.

Taking Aristotle’s maxims about logic and thinking, one only has to determine the intelligent outcome of whether something is true or false. Nothing more.

I’ll use Star Trek’s Spock’s often quoted decision-maker: “Do the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?” first spoken by Leonard Nimoy's Spock in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. However, philosopher Jeremy Bentham had a similar quote: "It is the greatest good to the greatest number of people which is the measure of right and wrong." [From the internet]

A computer – AI – that provides a quantitative answer to a problem using the Spockian maxim will have all the information it needs to act rightly and intelligently; no other information is necessary, if …

The if is that AI (the computer) must have within its data bank all the information that pertains, such as what are the consequences, good or bad, if AI makes a decision.

No emotional input or judgmental factors must intrude or should. This has been the downfall for all of mankind’s decision-making since the earliest intrusions of self-awareness or consciousness. [See Julian Jaynes particularly.]

The striving to make AI human-like is wrong-headed and derides the idea of intelligence as is being exampled currently in the mind- less behavior and actions of President Donald Trump’s followers and supporters.

If you’d like to continue this discussion, leave a civil comment or two and we’ll see where we might go with it.

RR

Book Collectors, not Book Readers

Copyright 2020, InterAmerica, Inc.

I’m finding by slightly surreptitious inquiries, mostly at Facebook, that many (most?) UFOers like to collect UFO and paranormal-topic books but rarely, if ever, read them, certainly not in toto.

Some collectors will scour the books they buy for a few things in them that they are particularly interested in, but eschew the bulk of the book.

Popular UFO writers – Philip Mantle, Nick Redfern, Kevin Randle, Malcolm Robinson, and others who are either first-timers or little-known outside their own constituencies – offer reads that provide info-worthy items.

But few collectors of their books and collectors of the classic UFO tomes released over the years are not reading the books. They scan and pull one or two pieces to discuss but, overall, the content is not perused, and not digested.

Even content added to Facebook groups or by UFO notables get scant rumination, relegated to likes or a pithy comment that means little or means nothing.

The state of “education” among UFO people and the whole UFO community is wanting and pathetic.

But you know that. And some of you are part of the problem, seekers of internet blurbs or YouTube presentations that sink in the memory, only to be recalled partially when you hope to make points, somewhere.

No wonder the UFO phenomenon remains unexplained.

RR